In April 2009, We Are The In Crowd's Myspace page was hacked. The hacker was an ex-member of the band and deleted all of their friends and music.[7] The news attracted the attention of someone at Hopeless Records who contacted the band shortly after.[citation needed] Jardine made a video on YouTube announcing the hack.
On November 10, 2009, the group announced their signing with Hopeless Records as "The In Crowd" and released their first single "For the Win" on iTunes. The band changed their name to "We Are The In Crowd" due to trademark issues with a reggae band from the seventies who were also called "The In Crowd".[8]
We Are The In Crowd entered the studio in early May 2011 to begin recording their full-length debut.[10] On August 3, 2011, it was announced the album would be titled Best Intentions, with a release date of October 4. It debuted on the U.S. Billboard 200 at No. 122. The band toured with acts such as All Time Low and Mayday Parade, and have appeared at Warped Tour in 2010 and 2012, and festivals such as Leeds. In 2013, the band toured around much of the world, including the UK.
The band announced via a Fuse video interview that they would be recording material for a new album. On August 20, 2013, they released their new single "Attention".
On the December 3, 2013, We Are The In Crowd announced that they would be releasing a new album entitled Weird Kids, set for release on the February 18, 2014. They also announced a UK tour in late January followed by a US tour. The second single from the album, "The Best Thing (That Never Happened)", was released on Spotify that same day, and due to the "overwhelming response" they released it on iTunes the same day, a few days early.
In August 2014 the band were announced as the support acts for British rock band Don Broco during their Kerrang! tour in February 2015.[11]
In February 2015, Taylor Jardine made a video announcement confirming that the band would soon begin writing and recording their third full-length album.[12]
On May 4, 2015, band members Mike Ferri, Cameron Hurley and Taylor Jardine all tweeted that the third full-length has been finished.[13]
On February 10, 2016, Taylor Jardine announced the band were going on hiatus.[14] During this hiatus, Jardine began performing under the name 'Sainte', with Cameron Hurley, Mike Ferri, and Rob Chianelli involved creatively.[15] Under this moniker, Jardine released the album "Smile, and Wave" in 2017,[16] and the EP "Bad Summer" in 2019.[17] As of 2024, the website for Sainte is no longer active, and the Instagram username redirects to an unrelated account.
On October 21, 2019, the band tweeted a graphic image of themselves dressed up as cowboys riding a horse, hinting at a potential reunion in the near future.[18] Two days later, that reunion was officially confirmed when it was announced that they would be playing at Slam Dunk Fest in the UK in 2020, before the coronavirus pandemic hit and Slam Dunk Fest had to be pushed back to September 2021.[19][20]
On November 16, 2023, the band shared that they would be performing at When We Were Young Festival in Las Vegas, Nevada. According to their own caption, this would mark their "first time on American soil since 2015".[21]