Garrett made his major league debut at second base,[3] and played most of his first month in the majors there. Shortly afterwards, the 21 year-old lefty hitter settled into a lefty-righty platoon with Ed Charles at third base. He batted just .218 with one home run his rookie season; however, he would match that home run total in the 1969 National League Championship Series against his former franchise. With the Atlanta Braves leading 4–3 in the fifth inning of game three, Garrett hit a go-ahead two run home run to seal the three-game sweep for the Mets.[4] For the NLCS, Garrett batted .385 with three runs batted in and three runs scored. He struck out in his only official at-bat in the World Series.[5]
After completing his military obligation and a brief stop at triple A Tidewater, Garrett rejoined his team midway through the 1971 season. He hit the ground running, going 3-for-5 with two RBIs and three runs scored in his first game back,[8] and 2-for-3 with two walks and an RBI in his second,[9] but he soon cooled off. An 0-for-29 skid at the end of the season saw his batting average drop to .213. Following the season, the Mets sent a package of young prospects that included Nolan Ryan to the California Angels for perennial All-Star third baseman Jim Fregosi.[10]
Garrett and Fregosi produced identical .232 batting averages in 1972, and combined for seven home runs and 61 RBIs platooning at third. Fregosi's tenure in New York lasted until midway through the 1973 season before his contract was sold to the Texas Rangers.
Ya Gotta Believe!
At the time of the deal, Garrett was batting .233 with six home runs and 27 RBIs. He batted .277 with 10 home runs and 31 RBIs over the remainder of the season. He led off the Mets' September 7 contest with the Montreal Expos with a solo home run that turned out to be the only run of the game.[11] On September 13, his extra inningspinch-hitsingle drove in the winning run against the Philadelphia Phillies.[12] From September 17 to September 21, the Mets played a crucial five-game stretch against the Pittsburgh Pirates that would determine the National League East. The Mets won four of those five games, and went from 3.5 games back to first place by half a game. Garrett went 8-for-22 during that stretch with a home run, two RBIs and five runs scored. He was also at the center of one of the most famous plays in Mets folklore. Their September 20 match-up at Shea Stadium went into extra innings. The Pirates had Richie Zisk on first base when Dave Augustine hit what appeared to be a two-run home run to left. Instead, the ball hit the top of the wall, and caromed directly into left fielderCleon Jones' glove. Jones fired a strike to Garrett as the cut-off man, who in turn, fired a strike to catcherRon Hodges to nail Zisk at the plate.[13] The Mets went on to win the game in the bottom of the inning.
Garrett went just 2-for-24 in the 1973 National League Championship Series against Cincinnati's "Big Red Machine," but one of those hits sparked the series-winning rally. With the score tied at two in the fifth and decisive game, Garrett led off the fifth inning with a double. The following batter, Félix Millán, laid down a sacrifice bunt. Rather than take the sure out at first base, RedspitcherJack Billingham threw to third, attempting to get the lead runner. Reds third baseman Dan Driessen tagged the base, not the runner, forgetting that there was no force on the play. Thereby, allowing both runners to be safe. The following batter, Cleon Jones, doubled to drive in Garrett with the lead run.[14]
Garrett hit two home runs in the 1973 World Series against the Oakland Athletics. The first coming in the Mets' 10–7 game two victory,[15] and the second came leading off game three.[16] Aside from these two home runs, he did not have much success, however. He batted just .167, and tied Eddie Mathews' 1958 World Series record by striking out eleven times. He also made the final out of the Series. Representing the tying run, he popped out to shortstop Bert Campaneris to end the game.[17]
1974-1976
After a career year in 1973, Garrett was finally handed the starting job at third for 1974. He appeared in a career high 151 games, and made a career high 619 plate appearances, but batted just .224 with 13 home runs. After the season, the Mets acquired former National League MVP Joe Torre from the St. Louis Cardinals for Tommy Moore and Ray Sadecki.
In 1975, Garrett batted .266 platooning with Torre at third. For 1976, Torre was shifted to first, and the third base job was split between Garrett and rookie Roy Staiger until midway through the season, when Garrett was dealt to the Montreal Expos with Del Unser for Pepe Mangual and Jim Dwyer.
Montreal Expos
With the Expos, Garrett was shifted to second base. On September 29, Garrett hit his first career grand slam against the Mets at Shea.[18] His career at second base was cut short when the Expos signed free agentsecond basemanDave Cash after the season. He spent the remainder of his Expos career backing up Larry Parrish at third. On July 21, 1978, two years from the date that he was acquired from the Mets, the Expos sent Garrett to the St. Louis Cardinals for cash considerations. His one home run with the Cards was a pinch hit grand slam.[19] Unable to come to an agreement on a contract for the 1979 season, Garrett decided to head to Japan, where his brother, Adrian, had been playing since 1977.
Garrett played 711 games at third base for the Mets. It is the third-highest total, behind David Wright and Howard Johnson.[20] Joe Foy, Bob Aspromonte, Jim Fregosi and Joe Torre combine for 384.
Garrett's nephew Jason (Adrian's son), was drafted by and played four years in the Florida Marlins organization, reaching High-A in the minor leagues.[23]
