He made six league appearances for Forest, but was reportedly not thought strong enough for top-class football, and moved on to Brighton & Hove Albion of the Southern League in May 1905. He worked on his physical conditioning at his new club, and became a regular at outside right in the first team with 13 goals from 119 appearances in all competitions over two and a half years. Described by club historian Tim Carder as "a tricky little ball-player, noted for the accuracy of his crosses with either foot", he attracted attention from bigger clubs.[1] After Brighton eliminated First Division Preston North End from the 1907–08 FA Cup after two replays,[5]Blackburn Rovers were convinced to sign Anthony and two teammates, Dick Wombwell and Joe Lumley, for "a substantial sum",[6] widely reported as £750.[7]The Football Association had recently imposed a rule forbidding more than £350 to be paid for any single player, and it was understood that Anthony was the primary target and Lumley and Wombwell were makeweights in the circumvention of that maximum.[8][9]
Anthony served in the Army in the First World War, and then worked in the mines. He spent 18 years in the dispatch department of a Nottingham car parts supplier, working until two days before his death in Basford in January 1950 at the age of 70.[14]
^ abcdefgCarder, Tim; Harris, Roger (1997). Albion A–Z: A Who's Who of Brighton & Hove Albion F.C. Hove: Goldstone Books. p. 15. ISBN978-0-9521337-1-1.
^ abcdJoyce, Michael (2004). Football League Players' Records 1888 to 1939. Nottingham: SoccerData. p. 10. ISBN978-1-899468-67-6.
^"Notts. and District League". Nottingham Evening Post. 11 January 1902. p. 3.
^"Sporting Notes". Nottingham Evening Post. 20 February 1904. p. 6. Nottingham Forest have signed a promising young local forward in Walter Anthony, the outside left of the Arnold club. Anthony has been a most consistent performer in Notts. League football, and many good judges who have seen him play prophesy a great future for him. The Arnold club, we understand, have received a cheque for £25 in connection with the transfer.
^"New players for Blackburn Rovers". Sheffield Independent. 15 February 1908. p. 9.
^"Brighton players for Blackburn". The Globe. London. 14 February 1908. p. 3.
^TAM (19 February 1908). "From the field. The Southern raid on the Football League". Bognor Regis Observer. p. 3. I have indicated all along how the law relating to the limitation of transfer fees may be evaded, and we have not had to wait long for a demonstration. Here we have Blackburn Rovers paying Brighton and Hove £750 for three players—Anthony, Wombwell, and Lumley. I do not suppose that Blackburn Rovers wanted all three men. They probably wanted only Anthony, but they had to take the others—and pay the price.
^Carder; Harris. Albion A–Z. p. 268. First Division Blackburn Rovers signed [Wombwell] along with Joe Lumley and their main target, Walter Anthony...