Colella grew up in New York and was a high school football star in his hometown of Albion, New York. He played four years of college football at Canisius College before being drafted by the NFL's Detroit Lions. He was on the Lions' roster for two years, after which he moved to the Rams in 1945 and the Browns of the AAFC in 1946. Colella stayed with the Browns for three years, in each of which the team won the AAFC championship. He spent the 1949 season with the Buffalo Bills before leaving football.
Early life and college
Colella grew up in Albion, New York, and played three sports at the city's Charles D'Amico High School. Was referenced as "The Albion Antelope."[1] After graduating, he attended Canisius College in Buffalo, New York, where he was a versatile football player for four years.[1] He was a running back, quarterback, defensive back, kicker and kick-return man at the school, and won Little All-America honors three years in a row.[1] He returned a kickoff for a touchdown and kicked two extra points in a Canisius Golden Griffins win over the then-undefeated Long Island Blackbirds in 1940.[1]
With the Browns, Colella was a punter and defensive halfback between 1946 and 1948.[2] Colella had 10 interceptions in 1946, leading the AAFC.[7] Cleveland coach Paul Brown said in 1948 that Colella provided "the type of punt we want against such dangerous receivers as the Rockets and Buffalo Bills have. All of his kicks have gone out of bounds, and our opponents have gained exactly no yards on returns in the last two games."[8] Cleveland won the AAFC championship in each of the three seasons he was with the team.[9]
Colella was traded to the Buffalo Bills in May 1949 along with Chet Adams, his former Rams teammate.[10] "We have won three championships, but we can't remain at a standstill," Brown said.[10] He played one season for the Bills before leaving football.[2]
Later life and death
In the 1950s, Colella stayed in Buffalo and worked as a salesman.[11] Colella was inducted into the Canisius College Athletics Hall of Fame as part of its inaugural class in 1963.[12] He was inducted into the Greater Buffalo Sports Hall of Fame in 2002, ten years after his death.[1]
^"Colella Stars in Rams Workout". Cleveland Plain Dealer. August 23, 1944. p. 14. Tommy Colella, triple-threat halfback obtained from the Detroit Lions, sparkled as the Cleveland Rams scrimmaged yesterday at Hiram.
^Dietrich, John (October 5, 1944). "2 Topnotch Punters Give Rams Chance to Jolt Bears". Cleveland Plain Dealer. p. 16. In Albie Reisz, the rookie from Lorain, and Tommy Colella, who was acquired from the Detroit Lions early in the season, the Rams have two of the best punters in the league – maybe the best. ... Colella has proved himself to be an outstanding climax runner, a fine passer and a great kicker.
^Dietrich, John (July 30, 1946). "Graham, Schwenk, Lewis Hope to 'T' Off For Browns". Cleveland Plain Dealer. p. 15. Tommy Colella, fleet halfback of the Rams in 1944 and 1945, who signed with the Browns shortly after the close of last season, got in today and worked out.