Joy Havenith (Love) is kept away from other young people so that she can inspire her grandfather's poetry. She is unhappy with her situation, and believes the "wishing ring man" (Glendon) when he says that, if she wishes hard enough, she will get everything she wants.
When she is given the opportunity to go to the city, her grandfather refuses to let her go because she is not engaged. Joy claims to be engaged to the doctor, and the doctor is forced to play along.[2][4][7]
^R.W.B. (March 8, 1919). "The Wishing Ring Man is Excellent Attraction". Exhibitor's Trade Review. Vol. 5, no. 14. p. 1067. A sweet, charming little story. Entertainment of the wholesome kind. A play that is refreshing. Acting that is delightful. A production of the best.
^"Bessie Love at Her Best". The Moving Picture World. March 8, 1919. p. 1380. Miss Love, in this production, sets for herself a mark which it will not be easy for her to surpass.
^"Strand Theatre". Shelby Beacon. Vol. 6, no. 3. Ellwood City, PA. April 25, 1919. p. 22. rare charm and talent …wonderfully interesting