The Spectator called it "a series of remarkable sketches and short stories...[2] they are especially interesting as showing the growth of his talent, but they are well worth reading for their intrinsic merit."[2]
The Sewanee Review noted "There are sixteen sketches in all and each is entitled to the place given it upon its particular merits rather than, as was the evident intention of the editor, of exhibiting therein the growth and development of the author's imagination and technique."[3]