The first episode of The Flop House was released in September 2007 and featured McCoy, Wellington, and original co-host Simon Fisher discussing the 2005 film Stealth. Following Fisher's departure from the show, Kalan became a permanent co-host in early 2008. The podcast has featured a guest host on several episodes, including multiple appearances by The Daily Show writer Hallie Haglund.
The Flop House was an independent production for several years before joining the All Things Comedy podcasting network in October 2012.[7] The podcast then moved to the Maximum Fun network in September 2014.[8]
Performing live as The Flop House, McCoy, Wellington, and Kalan co-hosted, along with the editors of film zineI Love Bad Movies, a series of bad movie screenings at 92YTribeca in New York City from June 2011[9] until the venue's closing[10] in June 2013.[11] They have since hosted a series of "Flop Night" screenings along with the editors of I Love Bad Movies at the Alamo Drafthouse Cinema in Yonkers, New York.[12]
In September 2014, it was announced McCoy, Wellington, and Kalan would cumulatively write a forty-page Flash Gordon Holiday Special comic book to be released in December 2014.[13]