The first time that the Famous Five all started together in a competitive match was on 15 October 1949 versus Queen of the South at Easter Road. The Edinburgh club won the match 2–0.[3] The first time they ever played together however, was in a pre-season friendly match against Nithsdale Wanderers at Sanquhar, when they won 7-2. The last match all five players started together was against Clyde at Easter Road on 29 January 1955. Despite Ormond and Reilly getting both on the scoresheet, the visitors won the match 3–2.[4]
It was due to this successful period that Hibs played in the inaugural European Cup in the 1955–56 season,[7] even though the club had only finished in 5th place in 1955, 15 points behind championsAberdeen.[8] The club reached the semi-finals of the European Cup, losing to Stade Reims.[9]
The forward line was never picked as a whole unit for a Scottish international side. Four of the players appeared in a Scottish League XI game in October 1952, with Turnbull replaced by Dundee player Billy Steel. Reilly scored four of the five Scotland goals.[10]