Nestor recruited by Carlton as an injury replacement player midway through the 2017 season.[1] She made her debut in the fourth round of the season against Melbourne at Casey Fields.[1] She was delisted at season's end after having played three matches at AFLW level.[2] In 2019, Nestor was drafted by North Melbourne.[3] After playing nine games in two seasons at the club, she was delisted in June 2021.[4]