Ben and Jamie are college freshmen and best friends since eighth grade. They are both in long-distance relationships with their high school sweethearts. Ben's girlfriend Claire is controlling, and Jamie pushes him to set boundaries. Jamie is bored of her boyfriend, Simon, and struggles to develop friendships due to childhood bullying. Ben pushes Jamie let her guard down and make friends. Unbeknownst to Jamie, Ben is planning to study abroad in Copenhagen next semester. He is afraid to tell her because he does not want her to feel abandoned.
At their first college party, Ben rebuffs the sexual advances of a drunken woman while Jamie sneaks into a bedroom to sext with Simon. Jamie is forced to leave her clothes in the room when two partygoers enter to have sex. Ben attempts to sneak into the room to retrieve Jamie's clothes but is caught. They are ejected from the party. Their friend Palmer reveals he is returning to their hometown in Ohio and will be hosting a coming out party the night beforeThanksgiving. Ben and Jamie decide they are going to end their relationships that night.
When Ben's roommate takes his car without permission, the duo's trip is delayed and they are forced to take the bus. Later at Palmer's, Claire and Simon drink an entire bottle of absinthe and drunkenly leave. With help from Reese, a local school football coach, Claire and Simon are safely returned. Palmer, realizing Reese is also gay, confides in him. Reese brings Palmer to a bowling alley and introduces his bowling team consisting of all gay men. Palmer finds newfound comfort and confidence.
Meanwhile, Ben and Jamie search for Claire and Simon at a bar. They are forced to sneak in, and Jamie is confronted by her childhood bully who asks for forgiveness which Jamie begrudgingly accepts. The bouncer catches them and they are thrown out. Frustrated, Ben and Jamie argue about their circumstances and become upset with one another. They learn Claire and Simon are at another party and head there. At the party, Palmer accidentally reveals to Jamie about Ben's plans to study abroad. Jamie realizes that she is the only one who did not know. Angry, she leaves to find Simon.
Claire attempts to seduce Ben in an outdoor tree fort, unbeknownst to Jamie, who is breaking up with Simon below. Ben and Claire overhear the conversation, and Claire becomes angry after learning Ben and Jamie planned the breakups together. Claire and Simon leave, believing Ben and Jamie are co-dependent and carrying out a secret romance. Ben and Jamie discuss their relationship, sharing a passionate kiss. As the party ends, the friends all return home.
On Thanksgiving, Ben watches When Harry Met Sally..., appearing to have an epiphany about Jamie. He confronts Jamie, revealing he regrets the kiss and does not hold romantic feelings toward her, and instead wants to remain friends. Jamie expresses relief; she reciprocates and wishes him well on his upcoming trip. Jamie meets with Simon and properly breaks up with him before returning to school. Ben does the same with Claire before leaving for Europe. Palmer begins a relationship with a local man named Lukas.
Six months later, Ben returns and surprises Jamie at her sorority's party. While dancing, they share loving glances.
Sweethearts was streamed on Max on November 28, 2024.[8]
Critical response
On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 62% of 21 critics' reviews are positive, with an average rating of 6.2/10.[9]Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned the film a score of 59 out of 100, based on nine critics, indicating "mixed or average" reviews.[10]
