The community originally formed in 1897 in Indian Territory under the name of Thomasville, about the time the Long-Bell Lumber Company purchased property there.[3][4] The company created a subsidiary, the King-Ryder Lumber Company (that was also in Bon Ami, Louisiana), which built a lumber mill at Thomasville and even a railway, the Kingston and Choctaw Valley Railroad, which ran from Thomasville to connect to other rail lines at Howe, Oklahoma.[3][4] King-Ryder left about 1901, but other timber operations continued in the area.[3]
The settlement was later reborn as Stapp, and had a Buschow Lumber Company sawmill.[5] Stapp had a post office beginning in 1918. However, the Buschow mill, a victim of its own "cut and move on" timber policies, closed in 1932, and the post office followed in 1944.[5] While at its height the population of the settlement was about 1,000, nothing remains of the old town today.