An external review concluded that 9 patients in the St. Joseph's Health System died by suicide in 2016 while being treated as patients or on a day pass. Two families of the deceased filed each filed a 8.5 million dollar negligence lawsuit against the St. Joseph's Health System in October 2017.[4]
During the COVID-19 pandemic in Ontario, St. Joseph's Villa had a COVID-19 outbreak starting November 2020, resulting in at least 55 infections and 8 deaths.[2]
Tom Stewart, the President and CEO of the St. Joseph's Health System, took an international holiday vacation to the Dominican Republic and other countries from December 18, 2020 until January 5, 2021, contrary to public health advice to avoid non-essential international travel. Upon his vacation being reported on by the press, Stewart apologized, said he regretted it, and stated that everyone should avoid non-essential travel. Union leaders representing Ontario Council of Hospital Unions/CUPE, the Registered Nurses' Association of Ontario, and SEIU Healthcare characterized Stewart's decision as "irresponsible" and poor leadership during a time that frontline health workers were struggling.[2] On January 7, 2021, a day after Niagara Health System terminated its CEO-sharing agreement with St. Joseph's Health System, Stewart was removed as President and CEO by the board of directors.[5]