Utz attended Annandale High School, where he practiced football and baseball. He contributed to the school winning four consecutive county football championships. As a senior, he received All-Met and All Northern Region honors.[2]
College career
Utz accepted a football scholarship from Virginia Tech. He was referred to as "Mr. Inside" as a fullback in the Tech offense that featured star quarterback Bob Schweickert, who was called "Mr. Outside."[3] He also played as a linebacker.
1962 season
Utz was one of four backs who ran for over 250 yards for the Gobblers, racking up 261 yards on 66 carries.[4] He scored one touchdown for the 5-5 Techmen.
1963 season
Utz led the conference in scoring for the only Virginia Tech team to ever win the Southern Conference title.[1] He scored 10 touchdowns in 10 games for the Hokies who finished the year 8-2 and with a perfect 5-0 conference mark.[4] He also was second to Sweickert on the team in rushing with 567 yards.[4] That was good enough for third place in the Southern Conference.[1]
1964 season
In the 1964 season, Utz led the Southern in both rushing and scoring.[1] However, the Hokies lost to West Virginia to spoil their bid for back-to-back Southern Conference championships. Utz scored 10 times on the ground in 10 games for the second straight year, but also caught a pass for a touchdown to tally a total of 66 points.[1]
Utz was selected by the Dallas Cowboys in the 6th round (75th overall) of the 1965 NFL draft.[5] He also was selected by the New York Jets in the 13th round (100th overall) of the 1965 AFL Draft.[6] He opted to sign with the Cowboys, but missed all of training camp due to ankle injury he suffered in a motorcycle accident the previous spring. On August 24, 1966, he was waived to be placed on the injured reserve list.[7]
^Schlabach, Mark; Wood, Norm; Glier, Ray (2011). Always a Hokie: Players, coaches and fans share their passion for Virginia Tech football. Chicago: Triumph Books.