Section 51(xxxi) of the Australian Constitution


Constitution of Australia
Chapters of the Constitution
Text of the Constitution
The full text of Constitution of Australia at Wikisource
flag Australia portal

Section 51(xxxi) is a subclause of section 51 of the Constitution of Australia.[1] It empowers the Commonwealth to make laws regarding the acquisition of property, but stipulates that such acquisitions must be on just (fair) terms. The subclause is sometimes referred to in shorthand as the 'just terms' provision.

Aside from its importance to Australian constitutional law and property law, the section is notable for its role as a plot device in the Australian film The Castle.

Text

Section 51(xxxi) reads: [1]

s.51 The Parliament shall, subject to this Constitution, have power to make laws for the peace, order, and good government of the Commonwealth with respect to:

...
(xxxi) the acquisition of property on just terms from any State or person for any purpose in respect of which the Parliament has power to make laws;
...

Jurisprudence

While s51(xxxi) was adapted from the US Constitution's Fifth Amendment, it has many differences.

The 'just terms' requirement has been held not to affect the state parliaments.

In Grace Bros Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth (1946), Justice Dixon stated that the inclusion of the condition was to "prevent arbitrary exercises of the power at the expense of a State or a subject."[2]

The interpretation of the terms "acquisition" and "just terms" by the High Court of Australia has had the effect, however, of limiting its protection of property rights. Moreover, it operates at any time the Commonwealth makes a compulsory acquisition of property. As such, it is a contingent guarantee rather than a general constitutional right or freedom to enjoy property rights.

The Commonwealth may only acquire property on just terms for a "purpose in respect of which the Parliament has power to make laws". This means that every law supported by s 51(xxxi) must not be supported by any other additional legislative power.

Property

The High Court of Australia has taken a wide view of the concept of "property". Several members of the court took the opportunity to consider the meaning of the term property in Minister of State for the Army v Dalziel (1944). Justice Starke said the term includes: "every species of valuable right and interest including real and personal property, incorporeal hereditaments such as rents and services, rights-of-way, rights of profit or use in land of another, and choses in action. Justice McTiernan confirmed the term property extends to tangible and intangible property.[3]

An example of the breadth of the concept of property in section 51(xxxi) is provided by Bank of New South Wales v Commonwealth (the Bank Nationalisation Case). In that case, federal legislation contemplated the acquisition of private banks through the vesting of shares in private banks in the Commonwealth, and later the appointment of directors by the Governor of the Commonwealth Bank. Justice Dixon characterised the provisions as removing effective control over the property of the private banks. He concluded that this was, in the essential sense, an acquisition of a proprietary right.[4]

While statutory licences have sometimes been equated with proprietary interests, the removal of rights enjoyed under a statutory licence does not typically constitute an acquisition of property within section 51(xxxi), as licence conditions are inherently susceptible to change.

Acquisition

For the purposes of section 51(xxxi), property must have been acquired by somebody, and the acquisition must be for a Commonwealth purpose.[5] This is in contrast to the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, where the destination does not matter – it is enough that the holder of property has been deprived of it.[6] Thus, in JT International SA v Commonwealth, the High Court held that the Commonwealth's plain tobacco packaging laws, which restricted the plaintiff's use of its trademark, did not involve the Commonwealth acquiring any property.[7] Similarly, in Cunningham v Commonwealth, the High Court held that changes to the retiring allowances and life Gold Pass for retired members of Parliament were not an acquisition of property.[8]

In P J Magennis Pty Ltd v Commonwealth the High Court held that a grant to NSW which was tied to NSW compulsorily acquiring property was invalid as an acquisition of property upon terms which were not just.[9] The validity of a grant in the absence of a requirement to acquire property was upheld in the later case of Pye v Renshaw.[10]

Just terms

Typically, a determination of just terms based on the market value of the property at the time of acquisition will be sufficient to satisfy the requirement of just terms. Unlike the "just compensation" requirement in the American Fifth Amendment, however, "just terms" imports no equivalence of market value. The arrangements offered must be "fair", or such that a legislature could reasonably regard them as "fair".[11] However, this judgment of "fairness" must take account of all the interests affected, not just those of the dispossessed owner.

The requirement of "just terms" does not necessarily require that a compensation package be presented as part of the acquisition scheme. It is sufficient that the scheme provides adequate procedures for determining fair compensation. However, the Court may scrutinise such procedures closely to ensure their adequacy.

There may be some acquisitions of property to which section 51(xxxi) does not apply, such as those made under laws supported exclusively by section 122 of the Constitution.[12][13][14]

Section 51(xxxi) is an exception to the norm for interpretation of the subsections of section 51, that one grant of power cannot be used to "read down" another. In this case, however, the Court will not allow another grant of power to be read so broadly as to circumvent the specific limitation to the power granted by section 51(xxxi).[15]

The Deakin government's Lands Acquisition Act 1906, largely drafted by Littleton Groom, was the first to deal with the compulsory acquisition of land by the federal government. Its most contentious provision was a clause authorising the federal government to grant mining leases and regulate mining on Commonwealth land. Responsibility for compulsory acquisition was initially placed with the Department of Home Affairs.[16]

The Chifley government's Darwin Lands Acquisition Act 1945 compulsorily acquired 53 acres (21 ha) of land owned by Chinese-Australians in Darwin, leading to the end of the local Chinatown. The legislation was suggested in 1943 by the Northern Territory's administrator Aubrey Abbott, who proposed a combination of compulsory acquisition and conversion of the land to leasehold in order to effect "the elimination of undesirable elements which Darwin has suffered from far too much in the past" and stated that he hoped to "entirely prevent the Chinese quarter forming again". He further observed that "if land is acquired from the former Chinese residents there is really no need for them to return as they have no other assets". The territory's civilian population had mostly been evacuated during the war and the former Chinatown residents returned to find their homes and businesses reduced to rubble.[17]

See also

See also: Category:Acquisition of property in the Australian Constitution cases

References

  1. ^ a b Constitution (Cth) s 51 Legislative powers of the Parliament.
  2. ^ Grace Brothers Pty Ltd v Commonwealth [1946] HCA 11, (1944) 72 CLR 269 (17 April 1946), High Court.
  3. ^ Minister of State for the Army v Dalziel [1944] HCA 4, (1946) 68 CLR 261 (17 April 1946), High Court.
  4. ^ Bank of New South Wales v Commonwealth [1948] HCA 7, (1948) 76 CLR 1 (11 August 1948), High Court (Australia).
  5. ^ Commonwealth v Tasmania (Tasmanian Dams case) [1983] HCA 21, (1983) 158 CLR 1 (1 July 1983), High Court.
  6. ^ Smith Kline & French Laboratories (Aust) Ltd v Department of Community Services and Health [1990] FCA 151 at para 150-151, (1990) 22 FCR 73 at pp 116-7 (16 May 1990), Federal Court (Australia).
  7. ^ JT International SA v Commonwealth [2012] HCA 43, (2011) 250 CLR 1 "judgment summary" (PDF). High Court. 5 October 2012.
  8. ^ Cunningham v Commonwealth [2016] HCA 39, (2016) 259 CLR 536 "judgment summary" (PDF). High Court. 12 October 2016.
  9. ^ P J Magennis Pty Ltd v Commonwealth [1949] HCA 66, (1949) 80 CLR 382 (1 December 1949), High Court.
  10. ^ Pye v Renshaw [1951] HCA 8, (1951) 84 CLR 58 (8 October 1951), High Court.
  11. ^ Durham Holdings Pty Ltd v New South Wales [2001] HCA 7, (2001) 205 CLR 399 (15 February 2001), High Court (Australia).
  12. ^ Constitution (Cth) s 122 Government of territories.
  13. ^ Teori Tau v Commonwealth [1969] HCA 62, (1997) 190 CLR 5134 (14 August 1997), High Court (Australia).
  14. ^ Newcrest Mining (WA) Ltd v Commonwealth [1997] HCA 38, (1969) 119 CLR 564 (9 December 1969), High Court (Australia).
  15. ^ Attorney-General (Cth) v Schmidt [1961] HCA 21, (1961) 105 CLR 361 at pp 371–2 per Dixon CJ (27 April 1961), High Court (Australia).
  16. ^ Carment, David (1975). Australian liberal: a political biography of Sir Littleton Groom, 1867-1936 (PDF) (PhD thesis). Australian National University. pp. 57–59.
  17. ^ Giese, Diana (1995). Beyond Chinatown (PDF). National Library of Australia. pp. 35–37. ISBN 0642106339.

Read other articles:

Migrazione dei poli

Questa voce sull'argomento fisica è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. La migrazione dei poli, cioè lo spostamento dei poli magnetici, i punti in cui le linee del Campo magnetico terrestre cadono perpendicolarmente sulla superficie della crosta terrestre, e la loro dislocazione in punti diversi rispetto ai poli geografici, è causata dal movimento convettivo (continuo nel tempo) del materia...

 

 

Dewan Menteri Uni Soviet

Artikel ini sudah memiliki daftar referensi, bacaan terkait, atau pranala luar, tetapi sumbernya belum jelas karena belum menyertakan kutipan pada kalimat. Mohon tingkatkan kualitas artikel ini dengan memasukkan rujukan yang lebih mendetail bila perlu. (Pelajari cara dan kapan saatnya untuk menghapus pesan templat ini) Dewan Menteri USSRСовет Министров СССРBekas markas besar Dewan MenteriInformasi lembagaDibentuk1946Nomenklatur lembaga sebelumnyaDewan Komisar RakyatDibubarka...

 

 

Pembagian administratif Nauru

Peta pembagian administratif tingkat pertama Nauru Pembagian administratif Nauru terdiri atas 14 distrik pada tingkat pertama yang dikelompokkan ke dalam 8 daerah pemilihan. lbsPembagian administratif OseaniaNegara berdaulat Australia Federasi Mikronesia Fiji Kepulauan Marshall Kepulauan Solomon Kiribati Nauru Palau Papua Nugini Samoa Selandia Baru Timor Leste1 Tonga Tuvalu Vanuatu Dependensi danwilayah lain Kepulauan Cocos (Keeling) Kepulauan Cook Guam Hawaii Kaledonia Baru Kepulauan Mariana...

Gamis Imam Israel

Gamis Imam Besar seperti yang dibuat oleh the Temple Institute. Gamis (Ibrani: מְעִילמְעִיל me'il), lengkapnya gamis baju efod (מְעִיל הָאֵפֹוד meil ha-ephod), adalah salah satu bagian pakaian kudus (bigdei kehunah) Imam Besar Israel. Gamis atau jubah yang dijelaskan dalam Keluaran 28:31–35 ini dipakai di sebelah dalam Baju Efod. Seperti semua pakaian imam, harus dibuat oleh pengrajin yang ahli, penuh dengan 'roh keahlian'.[1] Alkitab Ibrani Dalam bahasa ib...

 

 

Habitability of red dwarf systems

Possible factors for life around red dwarf stars This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Habitability of red dwarf systems – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (April 2017) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) An artist's impression of a young red dwarf surrounded by three pl...

 

 

List of Thor DM-18 Agena-A launches

A Thor-Agena launch vehicle, ready to launch the Discoverer 37 (KH-3) spacecraft, on 13 January 1962 Thor DM-18 Agena A or just Thor-Agena was a series of orbital launch vehicles. The rockets used the Douglas-built Thor first stage and the Lockheed-built Agena second stages. They are thus cousins of the more-famous Thor-Deltas, which founded the Delta rocket family. The first attempted launch of a Thor-Agena was in January 1959. The first successful launch was on 28 February 1959, launching ...

Berliner Zeitung

German daily newspaper For another newspaper in Berlin formerly published under the name Berliner Zeitung, see B.Z. (newspaper). Berliner ZeitungSample front pageTypeDaily newspaper (except Sundays)FormatRhenish (format)Owner(s)Holger FriedrichPublisherBerliner VerlagEditor-in-chiefTomasz KurianowiczFounded21 May 1945; 78 years ago (1945-05-21)LanguageGermanHeadquartersBerlin, GermanyCirculation148,000 (2010)ISSN0947-174XWebsitewww.berliner-zeitung.de The Berliner Zeitung (G...

 

 

Giovanni Simonelli (allenatore)

Giovanni Simonelli Nazionalità  Italia Calcio Ruolo Allenatore (ex portiere) Termine carriera 1979 - giocatore 2017 - allenatore Carriera Squadre di club1 1972-1973 Casertana0 (0)1973-1978 Paganese64 (-56)1975-1976 Casertana22 (-20)1978-1979 Frattese25 (-38) Carriera da allenatore 1980-1981 Afragolese1981-1982 Saviano1982-1983 Boys Caivanese1983-1984 Saviano1984-1985 Palmese1985-1986 Boys Caivanese1987-1988 Giugliano1988-1989 ...

 

 

National Highway 306 (India)

National highway in India National Highway 306Map of the National Highway 306 in redNH 306 at Assam-Mizoram borderRoute informationLength90 km (56 mi)Major junctionsFromSilchar, AssamToKolasib, Mizoram LocationCountryIndiaStatesAssam: 335 km (208 mi)Mizoram: 515 km (320 mi)PrimarydestinationsSilchar - Kolasib Highway system Roads in India Expressways National State Asian ← NH 54→ NH 306 National Highway 306 (NH 306) is a 90 km (56 mi) National ...

Kandangan, Pematang Bandar, Simalungun

Untuk tempat lain yang bernama sama, lihat Kandangan. KandanganNagoriGapura selamat datang di Nagori KandanganNegara IndonesiaProvinsiSumatera UtaraKabupatenSimalungunKecamatanPematang BandarKode pos21186Luas... km²Jumlah penduduk... jiwaKepadatan... jiwa/km² Kandangan merupakan salah satu nagori yang ada di kecamatan Pematang Bandar, kabupaten Simalungun, provinsi Sumatera Utara, Indonesia. Kantor Pangulu Nagori Kandangan lbsKecamatan Pematang Bandar, Kabupaten Simalungun, Sumatera Ut...

 

 

سفارة السويد في إيران

سفارة السويد في إيران السويد إيران الإحداثيات 35°48′04″N 51°28′32″E / 35.80103°N 51.47555°E / 35.80103; 51.47555 البلد إيران  المكان طهران الاختصاص إيران  الموقع الالكتروني الموقع الرسمي  تعديل مصدري - تعديل   سفارة السويد في إيران هي أرفع تمثيل دبلوماسي[1] لدولة السوي...

 

 

Oxford West and Abingdon (UK Parliament constituency)

Parliamentary constituency in the United Kingdom since 1983 Oxford West and AbingdonCounty constituencyfor the House of CommonsBoundary of Oxford West and Abingdon in OxfordshireLocation of Oxfordshire within EnglandCountyOxfordshireElectorate76,953 (December 2019)[1]Major settlementsAbingdon, Kidlington, Oxford (5 wards), RadleyCurrent constituencyCreated1983Member of ParliamentLayla Moran (Liberal Democrats)SeatsOneCreated fromOxford, Abingdon Oxford West and Abingdon is a constitue...

Pavo de Nochebuena

Este artículo o sección necesita referencias que aparezcan en una publicación acreditada. Busca fuentes: «Pavo de Nochebuena» – noticias · libros · académico · imágenesEste aviso fue puesto el 13 de diciembre de 2017. Pavo de Nochebuena Pavo de Nochebuena Pavo asado Tipo Cena (variable)ConsumoOrigen DesconocidoDatos generalesSimilares Turducken[editar datos en Wikidata] El pavo de Nochebuena se come tradicionalmente durante el transcurso de la festivi...

 

 

2014 Daventry District Council election

2014 UK local government election This article relies largely or entirely on a single source. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please help improve this article by introducing citations to additional sources.Find sources: 2014 Daventry District Council election – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (July 2019) The 2014 Daventry District Council election took place on 22 May 2014 to elect members of Daventry District Council in ...

 

 

George Madison Millard House

Historic house in Illinois, United States United States historic placeGeorge Madison Millard HouseU.S. National Register of Historic Places LocationHighland Park, IllinoisCoordinates42°10′59.03″N 87°47′7.31″W / 42.1830639°N 87.7853639°W / 42.1830639; -87.7853639Built1906ArchitectFrank Lloyd WrightArchitectural stylePrairie SchoolNRHP reference No.82002571[1]Added to NRHPSeptember 29, 1982 The George Madison Millard House, is a Frank L...

Serpente (costellazione)

SerpenteMappa della costellazioneNome latinoSerpens GenitivoSerpentis AbbreviazioneSer CoordinateAscensione retta15,5 h Declinazione10° Area totale637 gradi quadrati Dati osservativiVisibilità dalla TerraLatitudine min+80° Latitudine max-80° Transito al meridiano30 giugno, alle 21:00 Stella principaleNomeUnukalhai (α Ser) Magnitudine app.2,7 Altre stelleMagn. app. < 31 Magn. app. < 667 Costellazioni confinantiDa est, in senso orario: Corona Boreale Boote Vergine Bilancia Ofiuco Erc...

 

 

Bleecker Street Cinema

Former movie theater in Greenwich Village, Manhattan, New York City, United States Bleecker Street CinemaBleecker Street Cinema, looking east.Former namesMori (1883–1937)MontparnasseAddress144 Bleecker StreetNew York City, New YorkLocation144 Bleecker StreetManhattan, New York City, New YorkOwnerPlacido Mori, New York University, Lionel Rogosin, Sid Geffen, Jackie Raynal, John SoutoTyperestaurant, art house movie theatreCapacity200ConstructionBuilt1832Opened1883 (1883)Renovated1883, 19...

 

 

Serie B 1969-1970

Serie B 1969-1970 Competizione Serie B Sport Calcio Edizione 38ª Organizzatore Lega Nazionale Professionisti Date dal 14 settembre 1969al 14 giugno 1970 Luogo  Italia Partecipanti 20 Formula girone unico Risultati Vincitore Varese(2º titolo) Altre promozioni FoggiaCatania Retrocessioni ReggianaPiacenzaGenoa Statistiche Miglior marcatore Roberto Bettega Aquilino Bonfanti Ariedo Braida(13 a testa) Incontri disputati 380 Gol segnati 581 (1,53 per incontro) I varesini pr...

Olympiska sommarspelen 1960

Den här artikeln behöver källhänvisningar för att kunna verifieras. (2019-09) Åtgärda genom att lägga till pålitliga källor (gärna som fotnoter). Uppgifter utan källhänvisning kan ifrågasättas och tas bort utan att det behöver diskuteras på diskussionssidan. Olympiska sommarspelen 1960 Grenar150 grenar i 17 sporterDeltagareNationer83Aktiva5 338Män4 727Kvinnor611VärdskapLand ItalienOrtRomArenaRoms OlympiastadionInvigning25 augusti 1960Spelen öppnades avItaliens presid...

 

 

Women's suffrage in Francoist Spain and the democratic transition

Part of a series onFrancoism Organizations Movimiento Nacional FET y de las JONS Council of the Realm National Council of the Movement Spanish Syndical Organization Frente de Juventudes Sección Femenina Armed Police Corps General Police Corps Tribunal de Orden Público Instituto Nacional de Colonización Instituto Nacional de Industria Fuerzas Armadas de España Cortes Españolas Sindicato Español Universitario Servicio Exterior de Falange History Spanish coup of July 1936 Spanish Civil Wa...