He is largely remembered as a moderate. As a progressive for his time, Messmer opposed segregationist church policies based on race or language, and he was a major supporter of expanding Catholic-run welfare programs. But he also pushed back against socialism as the movement was growing in Wisconsin, and he opposed women gaining the right to vote.
Messmer was ordained to the priesthood by Bishop Atanasio Zuber on July 23, 1871.[5] A week later, he offered his first Mass in Goldach.[2] He accepted an invitation from Bishop James Bayley, who had visited Innsbruck to recruit missionaries for the United States, to join the Diocese of Newark in New Jersey.[1]
During his 11-year tenure, Messmer encouraged the growth of parochial schools and other religious institutions.[7] He also invited Abbot Bernard Pennings to establish the Norbertine Order in the United States, which led to the founding of St. Norbert College in De Pere.[7]
Archbishop of Milwaukee
On November 28, 1903, Messmer was appointed the fourth archbishop of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee by Pope Pius X.[5] He was installed on December 10, 1903.[5] He succeeded Archbishop Frederick Katzer.[8]
Early in his time as archbishop, Messmer sought to create more unity among diverse congregations, resisting so-called conservative "Germanizers" and becoming known as an "assimilationist." This was because Messmer supported the church's more progressive faction in Wisconsin by encouraging English education and bilingual church services, rather than encouraging services to continue being provided in solely German to Milwaukee's large German American population; he supported a mandate for there to be at least one English language sermon in every parish. "Messmer deliberately de-emphasized ethnic self-consciousness as part of a design to unify and mobilize Catholics for social action," states one article published in the U.S. Catholic Historian journal. Messmer resisted clerical factions to be formed along the lines of nationality, despite earlier support for such formations and some Polish American Catholics accusing him of being a German nationalist. He also campaigned against the Bennett Law, which allowed children under the age of 14 to work; Messmer emphasized education over participation in the workforce for American youth.[9]
An opponent of Prohibition in the United States, Messmer issued a pastoral letter in 1918, declaring, "[People] fail to see the absolutely false principle underlying the movement and the sinister work of the enemies of the Catholic Church trying to profit by this opportunity of attacking her in the most sacred mystery entrusted to her."[10] In 1921, he prohibited Catholic children in Milwaukee from participating in a Fourth of July Pilgrim pageant, which he described as "exclusively a glorification of the ProtestantPilgrims," but later withdrew his objections.[6] Messmer was also opposed to women's suffrage.[6] He denounced the labor movement as being tinged with socialism and drew criticism from Polish Catholics after condemning the Kuryer Polski newspaper.[11]
During his 26-year tenure, Messmer oversaw the establishment of Mount Mary College in Milwaukee and the elevation of Marquette College to Marquette University.[8] He actively supported the American Federation of Catholic Societies as well as ministries for African American and Hispanic Catholics.[8] Nearly 30 religious orders were founded and charitable institutions were doubled during his administration; what became Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, a nonprofit that still exists today, was founded in 1920 under Messmer with the intent to serve the needs of the poor.[13] He founded the Catholic Herald, the official newspaper of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, in 1922.
Messmer died on March 4, 1930, while vacationing in his Goldach, at age 82.[4] At the time of his death, he was the oldest Catholic bishop in the United States.[6] He is buried in Goldach.[4]
