In 2021, Kroeger was a key member of a dominant Rutgers team that went undefeated in Big Ten conference play, winning all ten of their conference matches. The team advanced to the finals of the Big Ten tournament, marking just the third finals appearance in Rutgers history, though they were defeated by Michigan.[3] Rutgers also made it to the College Cup for the second time in its history, where they were eliminated by Florida State.[4]
In 2022, Kroeger and teammate Allison Lowrey both led the team in scoring with seven goals each.
Club career
Morris Elite SC
Kroeger joined Morris Elite SC in the USL W League in 2023. Since the USL W League is not classified as a professional league, it does not conflict with NCAA regulations. During the season, she appeared in 11 matches and contributed to the team's victory in the Metropolitan Division. Morris Elite qualified for the playoffs, where Kroeger made one appearance.[5]
Brooklyn FC
Kroeger wasn't drafted in the 2024 NWSL Draft.[6] Later that year on July 3, 2024, it was announced that Kroeger agreed to join Brooklyn FC for the inaugural USL Super League season.[7] Kroeger made her professional debut on September 8, 2024, starting in Brooklyn FC's inaugural match against Spokane.[8] On September 25, she was named Player of the Match for her performance in a game against Dallas.
Kroeger scored her first professional goal on October 27 in a home match against Fort Lauderdale United FC.
^Lashley, Josh. "Elevating their game", West Milford Messenger, November 28, 2021. Accessed September 29, 2024. "Samantha Kroeger, a graduate of West Milford High School is a sophomore midfielder and forward for the Rutgers University (New Brunswick campus) women’s soccer team this year."