In 2009, Hoare played for the Townsville Stingers in the Mal Meninga Cup.[3] Later that season, he made his debut for the Cowboys' NYC, for whom he played for until 2011. In 2011, Hoare suffered a season-ending knee injury, missing the NYC Grand Final.[4]
In 2012, Hoare moved into the Cowboys' NRL squad and played for the club's Queensland Cup affiliate, the Mackay Cutters. On 28 June 2012, Hoare re-signed with the Cowboys on a 2-year contract.[5] In 2013, Hoare played for the Queensland Residents and was a member of the Mackay side that won the Queensland Cup Grand Final.[6]
In 2014, Hoare was again selected for the Queensland Residents,[9] but had to withdraw due to being called up for his NRL debut.[10]
2015
In January 2015, Hoare was a member of the newly established QAS Emerging Maroons squad.[11] He played 8 games for the Cowboys in 2015, starting at prop in the side's 8–0 win over the Wests Tigers in Round 11.
In Round 3 of the 2017 NRL season, Hoare returned from his ACL knee injury, coming off the bench in the Cowboys' 30–8 loss to the Manly Sea Eagles. He finished the season with four NRL games, spending the majority of the season with the Townsville Blackhawks.
2018
Hoare played three games for the Cowboys in 2018, spending the majority of the season playing for the Mackay Cutters. In the Cowboys' Round 15 loss to the Warriors he tore his ACL for the third team and was ruled out for the season.[14]
On 13 September 2018, he was announced by the Cowboys as one of nine players leaving the club at the end of the 2018 season.[15]