McCall competed with Marie McNeil early in his career. They were the 1975 Canadian novice silver medallists, 1977 Canadian junior national champions, 1978 & 1979 Canadian senior bronze medallists, 1980 silver medallists, and the 1981 national champions. They placed 13th at the 1980 World Figure Skating Championships and the 1981 World Figure Skating Championships.
In 1988, Wilson and McCall were made a Member of the Order of Canada.
In March 1990, whilst in Portland, Maine, on tour with a show, McCall became critically ill with pneumonia. He was diagnosed with AIDS. Hoping to be able to continue to skate professionally in the United States (which then had restrictive immigration and customs laws barring persons with AIDS) he kept the nature of his illness secret [3] However, his health deteriorated and he died of AIDS-related brain cancer on November 15, 1991, at age 33.[4] It was an open secret that he was gay.[5]
In 2018 McCall was named one of the greatest 15 athletes in Nova Scotia's history.[6]