Reference Re BC Motor Vehicle Act

Reference Re BC Motor Vehicle Act
Supreme Court of Canada
Hearing: November 15, 1984
Judgment: December 17, 1985
Full case nameReference Re Section 94(2) of the Motor Vehicle Act
Citations[1985] 2 SCR 486
Docket No.17590[1]
Prior historyOn appeal from the BCCA
RulingAppeal was dismissed
Holding
Absolute liability offences cannot carry a possibility of imprisonment under the Charter
Court membership
Chief Justice: Brian Dickson
Puisne Justices: Roland Ritchie, Jean Beetz, Willard Estey, William McIntyre, Julien Chouinard, Antonio Lamer, Bertha Wilson, Gerald Le Dain
Reasons given
MajorityLamer J (paras 1–98), joined by Dickson CJ and Beetz, Chouinard and Le Dain JJ
ConcurrenceMacIntyre J (paras 99–100)
ConcurrenceWilson J (paras 101–131)
Ritchie and Estey JJ took no part in the consideration or decision of the case.

Reference Re BC Motor Vehicle Act, [1985] 2 SCR 486, was a landmark reference submitted to the Supreme Court of Canada regarding the constitutionality of the British Columbia Motor Vehicle Act. The decision established one of the first principles of fundamental justice in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms ("Charter"), beyond mere natural justice, by requiring a fault component for all offences with penal consequences. The decision also proved important and controversial for establishing fundamental justice as more than a procedural right similar to due process, but also protects substantive rights even though such rights were counter to the intent of the initial drafters of the Charter.[2]

Background

Section 94(2) of the Motor Vehicle Act of British Columbia created an absolute liability offence of driving while with a suspended licence. To obtain a conviction, the Crown needed only to establish proof of driving regardless of whether the driver was aware of the suspension. A successful conviction carried a prison term of a minimum of seven days.

The British Columbia Court of Appeal held that the Act violated a principle of fundamental justice under section 7 of the Charter.

Decision

Lamer J, writing for a unanimous court, held that an absolute liability, which makes a person liable for an offence whether he or she took steps not to be at fault, violates the principles of fundamental justice. Therefore, any possibility of a deprivation of life, liberty or security of person from an absolute liability offence offends the Charter. A law that violates section 7 cannot be saved by section 1 of the Charter except for extreme circumstances (for example, natural disasters, outbreaks of war, epidemics). The principles of fundamental justice impose a stricter test than section 1. Thus, any law that violates the principles of fundamental justice will most likely not be saved by section 1.

In surveying means of interpreting the constitution, Lamer dismissed the practice of relying on the testimony of the original drafters of the Constitution as interpretive aids and effectively rejected the use of an original intent approach to constitutional interpretation. Reference was made to the living tree doctrine.[3]

The Court also rejected the more restricted definition of fundamental justice under the Canadian Bill of Rights, as described in Duke v R.[4]

The Court noted the alternative view of fundamental justice as natural justice would have been an easier requirement for the government to satisfy. That would limit the rights to life, liberty, and security of person, or, as the Supreme Court put it, place the rights "in a sorely emaciated state". Liberty, for example, would be seen as not as comprehensive a right as section 9, which guards against arbitrary arrest and detention. Security of person would also be less comprehensive than section 8 rights against unreasonable search and seizure. Such an interpretation, the Court decided, would be inconsistent with the normal reading of the Charter, demonstrated in Law Society of Upper Canada v Skapinker[5] and Hunter v Southam Inc,[6] which was meant to be generous.[7] Lamer added that sections 8 to 14 should be seen as provided examples of principles of fundamental justice.

Another reason for discarding the Duke interpretation of fundamental justice was the difference in wording between the Bill of Rights and the Charter. In guaranteeing fundamental justice, the Bill of Rights references a "fair hearing". Section 7 does not mention a fair hearing, and the only context for fundamental justice is the "much more fundamental rights" of life, liberty and security of person.[8]

See also

References

  1. ^ SCC Case Information - Docket 17590 Supreme Court of Canada
  2. ^ This distinction was later relied upon in R v Morgentaler, [1988] 1 SCR 30 and Chaoulli v Quebec (AG), 2005 SCC 35.
  3. ^ Reference Re Motor Vehicle Act, para 53.
  4. ^ [1972] SCR 917 [Duke].
  5. ^ [1984] 1 SCR 357.
  6. ^ [1984] 2 SCR 145.
  7. ^ Paras 26–28.
  8. ^ Paras 57–58.

Read other articles:

Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada Februari 2023. Kaisar Nikolai dapat merujuk pada; Nikolai I dari Rusia (1796–1855), Kaisar Rusia (1825–1855) Nikolai II dari Rusia (1868–1918), Kaisar Rusia (1894–1917) Halaman disambiguasi ini berisi artikel dengan judul yang sering dikaitkan dengan Kaisar ...

 

 

Peta Bourgogne-Franche-Comté. Bourgogne-Franche-Comté (disingkat BFC) merupakan salah satu region di Prancis yang terbentuk saat terjadi reformasi teritorial region Prancis pada tahun 2014, dan merupakan gabungan dua daerah yaitu Bourgogne dan Franche-Comté. Daerah baru ini diresmikan setelah pemilihan daerah di bulan Desember 2015, tepatnya pada 1 Januari 2016.[1] Bourgogne-Franche-Comté merupakan sebuah nama sementara, dengan menggabungkan nama kedua daerah secara alfabetis; Dew...

 

 

German city, capital of Schleswig-Holstein For other uses, see Kiel (disambiguation). This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Kiel – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2020) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) City in Schleswig-Holstein, GermanyKiel CityMid-August 2003 ...

Cet article est une ébauche concernant un coureur cycliste belge. Vous pouvez partager vos connaissances en l’améliorant (comment ?). Pour plus d’informations, voyez le projet cyclisme. Georges ClaesInformationsNom court Жорж Клас ст.Naissance 7 janvier 1920BoutersemDécès 14 mars 1994 (à 74 ans)LouvainNationalité belgeÉquipes professionnelles 1939-1941Dilecta-Wolber1942Thompson1942-1943Helyett-Hutchinson1944Trialoux-Wolber1946-1948Rochet-Dunlop1947-1952Thompson...

 

 

Voce principale: Ghetti nazisti. Ghetto di VilniusGhetto Wilna Una strada del ghetto di Vilnius Stato Lituania CittàVilnius Data istituzione1941 Abitanti40 000 ab. (30 agosto 1941 - 23 settembre 1943) Coordinate: 54°41′N 25°19′E / 54.683333°N 25.316667°E54.683333; 25.316667 Il Ghetto di Vilnius, in lingua tedesca Ghetto Wilna, fu uno dei maggiori tra i ghetti nazisti istituiti nel corso della seconda guerra mondiale dal Terzo Reich nei territori occupati de...

 

 

Untuk kegunaan lain, lihat Sandi (disambiguasi). Artikel ini tidak memiliki referensi atau sumber tepercaya sehingga isinya tidak bisa dipastikan. Tolong bantu perbaiki artikel ini dengan menambahkan referensi yang layak. Tulisan tanpa sumber dapat dipertanyakan dan dihapus sewaktu-waktu.Cari sumber: Sandi fonologi – berita · surat kabar · buku · cendekiawan · JSTOR Sandhi, adalah perubahan fonetis yang terjadi di dalam sebuah kata pada posisi awa...

This biography of a living person relies too much on references to primary sources. Please help by adding secondary or tertiary sources. Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced must be removed immediately, especially if potentially libelous or harmful.Find sources: Tom Kane film producer – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (June 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Thomas John K...

 

 

Socialist republic in Eastern Europe (1946–1990) People's Republic of BulgariaНародна република България1946–1990 Flag(1971–1990) Coat of arms(1971–1990) Anthem: Maritsa Rushes  (1946–1947)Шуми Марица  (Bulgarian)Shumi Maritsa  (transliteration) Our Republic, Hail!  (1947–1951)Републико наша, здравей!  (Bulgarian)Republiko nasha, zdravey!  (transliteration)Dear Bu...

 

 

Public transit authority of the state of Maryland Not to be confused with Maryland Transportation Authority. This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (July 2015) Maryland Transit AdministrationMTA's headquarters at the William Donald Schaefer Building in BaltimoreOverviewLocaleWashington-Baltimore metropolitan areaTransit typeBus, Light rail, Rapid transit, Commuter railNumber of linesHeavy rail: 1Light rail: 3C...

Indonesian Television Awards 2016Logo Indonesian Television AwardsTanggal15 September 2016 (2016-09-15)LokasiStage 14, MNC StudiosJakarta BaratNegara IndonesiaPembawa acaraDaniel ManantaDeddy CorbuzierGisella AnastasiaPembawa pra-acaraDimas DanangImam DartoPenampilanJin GooAlan WalkerSiti NurhalizaIkhtisarPrime Time DramaAnak JalananPrime Time Non-DramaStand Up Comedy AcademyAktorAliando SyariefAktrisPrilly LatuconsinaPenghargaan khususJin Goo(Descendants of the Sun)Siaran televisi/...

 

 

保良局馬錦明夫人章馥仙中學Po Leung Kuk Mrs.Ma-Cheung Fook Sien College翻漆後的校舍東北面(2022年3月)地址 香港新界離島區大嶼山東涌富東邨类型津貼中學宗教背景無隶属保良局创办日期1997年学区香港離島區東涌校長柯玉琼女士副校长鄭健華先生,劉俊偉先生助理校长梁煥儀女士职员人数56人年级中一至中六学生人数約700人,24個班別校訓愛、敬、勤、誠校歌保良局屬下校歌�...

 

 

American humorist, author, director and music producer Sandra BoyntonBoynton around 2005Born (1953-04-03) April 3, 1953 (age 71)Orange, New Jersey, U.S.Education Yale University (BA) University of California, Berkeley Occupations Illustrator Cartoonist Humorist Author Songwriter WebsiteOfficial website Sandra Keith Boynton (born April 3, 1953) is an American humorist, songwriter, director, music producer, children's author, and illustrator. Boynton has written and illustrated over sevent...

Municipality in Rizal, Philippines Municipality in Calabarzon, PhilippinesBinangonanMunicipalityMunicipality of BinangonanBinangonan in 2012 FlagSealMotto(s): Center of Education and Good GovernanceAnthem: Binangonan MarchMap of Rizal with Binangonan highlightedOpenStreetMapBinangonanLocation within the PhilippinesCoordinates: 14°27′05″N 121°11′31″E / 14.4514°N 121.1919°E / 14.4514; 121.1919CountryPhilippinesRegionCalabarzonProvinceRizalDistrict 1st di...

 

 

National Standard TimeNational Standard Time digital clock of Bureau of Standards, Metrology and Inspection (BSMI), Taiwan.Traditional Chinese國家標準時間Simplified Chinese国家标准时间TranscriptionsStandard MandarinHanyu PinyinGuójiā Biāozhǔn ShíjiānBopomofoㄍㄨㄛˊ ㄐㄧㄚ ㄅㄧㄠ ㄓㄨㄣˇ ㄕˊ ㄐㄧㄢGwoyeu RomatzyhGwojia Biaujuun ShyrjianWade–GilesKuo²-chia¹ Piao¹-chun³ Shih²-chien¹Tongyong PinyinGuójia Biaojhǔn ShíhjianMPS2Guójiā Biā...

 

 

99th President of the Swiss Confederation Ignazio CassisOfficial portrait, 2024President of SwitzerlandIn office1 January 2022 – 31 December 2022Vice PresidentAlain BersetPreceded byGuy ParmelinSucceeded byAlain BersetVice President of SwitzerlandIn office1 January 2021 – 31 December 2021PresidentGuy ParmelinPreceded byGuy ParmelinSucceeded byAlain BersetMember of the Swiss Federal CouncilIncumbentAssumed office 1 November 2017DepartmentForeign Affairs (2017–presen...

Trade paperback imprint of the Crown publishing group The topic of this article may not meet Wikipedia's notability guidelines for companies and organizations. Please help to demonstrate the notability of the topic by citing reliable secondary sources that are independent of the topic and provide significant coverage of it beyond a mere trivial mention. If notability cannot be shown, the article is likely to be merged, redirected, or deleted.Find sources: Three Rivers Press – ...

 

 

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: GameSurge – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (February 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this message) GameSurgeFoundedFebruary 2004Geographic locationUnited StatesEuropeBased inWorldwideExecutive boardOrganizationWebsite URLwww.gamesurge.netPrimar...

 

 

كسر الفخذ كسر الفخذ معلومات عامة الموقع التشريحي عظم فخذ  تعديل مصدري - تعديل   كسر الفخذ (بالإنجليزية: Femoral fracture)‏ عبارة عن كسر عظم الفخذ، وعادةً ما يتم تحمل الكسر في حالات الصدمات شديدة التأثير مثل حوادث السيارات نظرًا للكمية الكبيرة من القوة اللازمة لكسر هذه العظمة،...

Vienna U-Bahn station Messe-PraterGeneral informationLocationLeopoldstadt, ViennaAustriaCoordinates48°13′04″N 16°24′20″E / 48.2179°N 16.4056°E / 48.2179; 16.4056Line(s)HistoryOpened2008Services Preceding station Wiener Linien Following station Pratersterntoward Karlsplatz U2 Krieautoward Seestadt Messe-Prater is a station on U2 of the Vienna U-Bahn.[1] It is located in the Leopoldstadt District. It opened in 2008. References ^ Vienna U2 line Externa...

 

 

2005 EP by Deathspell OmegaKénôseEP by Deathspell OmegaReleasedOctober 4, 2005Genre Black metal avant-garde metal Length36:20LabelNorma Evangelium DiaboliDeathspell Omega chronology Si monvmentvm reqvires, circvmspice(2004) Kénôse(2005) Fas – Ite, Maledicti, in Ignem Aeternum(2007) Kénôse is an EP by the black metal band Deathspell Omega, released in 2005 under The Ajna Offensive. It continues the avant-garde and progressive direction they had been exploring on 2004's Si monv...