In its inaugural campaign, Real Central NJ's WPSL team placed second in the Metropolitan Conference South. After besting MatchFit Academy in the semi-finals, the team lost to the NJ/NY Gotham FC Reserve team in the conference finals.[6]
The club's women's program is coached by Brian Thomsen, the Technical Director of Next Level Soccer Academy in Pennington, NJ.[7] The men's first team inaugural coach was Patrick Snyder, former college and PDA Soccer staff coach. Following the 2021 season, retiring William Patterson men's head coach Brian Woods was named to the clubs USL team top job.[8]
In 2022, the RCNJ WPSL team topped the Mid-Atlantic Conference with a record of 6-1-1.[9] The team secured the title on the last matchday of the season with a 3-2 home victory against Lehigh Valley Tempest, earning the club the duty of hosting the Eastern Region Playoffs.[10] The team lost to VT Fusion in the regional semi-final in kicks from the penalty mark after 120 minutes of scoreless play.
In 2023, the club's USL2 side placed 3rd in the Mid-Atlantic Conference with a 6-6-2 record. Among the season highlights was attacker Stas Korzeniowski's 18 minute hat-trick against Philadelphia Lone Star in the opening match of the season. The club believes this to be the fastest hat-trick in league history.[11][user-generated source?]
In November 2022 RCNJ and the United Soccer Leagues announced the club would explore professional expansion efforts. According to a joint press release, "The USL League Two side is aiming to bring men's and women's professional soccer to Central Jersey."[13] No additional details have been publicly released. In April 2024, League One Updater stated a reliable source stated "while the project is active and progressing, it is still in the early stages, indicating a jump in 2026 at the very earliest."[14]