Dillhoefer went on to appear in just eight games for the Phillies. He was later traded to the St. Louis Cardinals, where he played regularly for three years. Meanwhile, Alexander went on to win 183 games for the Cubs and Cardinals before ending his career in 1930 with the Phillies, and was later inducted to the National Baseball Hall of Fame.
While his career was undistinguished, Dillhoefer was still young when he died from typhoid fever in the winter of 1921–1922. He is remembered for his colorful nickname, a play on dill pickles.