In his last act in office in January 1967, Geer presided over the legislative vote in the deadlocked gubernatorial race between Democrat Maddox and RepublicanU.S. RepresentativeHoward Callaway. The impasse resulted because former Governor Ellis Arnall, an Atlanta lawyer, polled more than 52,000 ballots as a write-in candidate. Under the 1824 Georgia State Constitution, the legislature was required to choose between Callaway and Maddox as the top two candidates. Though Geer supported Maddox and ordered all legislators to vote, eleven lawmakers, including the African American Representative Julian Bond, refused to do so. The heavily Democratic assembly nevertheless voted 182 to 66 for Maddox. As Maddox took office, George Thornewell Smith succeeded Geer as lieutenant governor.[3]
Geer then returned to the practice of law. In 1973, Geer prosecuted four men accused of slaying six Alday family members in Seminole County, Georgia.[4] Geer obtained convictions and death sentences for the three principal defendants, although the convictions were later overturned because of pre-trial publicity which was held to have unduly prejudiced the jury. Later U.S. PresidentJimmy Carter, then the governor of Georgia, called the mass murder "the most heinous in Georgia history".[1]
Geer died of cancer at the Miller County Hospital in Colquitt and was buried in the city cemetery.[5]
^Schwartz, Jerry; Times, Special To the New York (January 4, 1988). "1973 Georgia Murders Back in Courts". The New York Times. Retrieved March 17, 2019 – via NYTimes.com.