A Democrat, Kinsey served as a Mecklenburg Countycommissioner from 1990 to 1994. She was then elected as a member of the Charlotte City Council from District 1 for five consecutive terms, from 2003 until the Council elected her Mayor on July 1, 2013, minutes after Foxx resigned from office.[1][2] North Carolina state law required that Foxx's appointed successor be of the same political party.[1] Both Kinsey and Foxx are members of the Democratic Party and Democrats held a 9-2 majority on the city council in July 2013.[1] Five Democratic city council members and one Republican member, Warren Cooksey, voted for Kinsey.[1] Two Democratic council members, Beth Pickering and Claire Fallon, voted against Kinsey.[1] Three other council members - Republican Andy Dulin and Democrats Patrick Cannon and Michael Barnes - missed the meeting and did not vote.[1]
Kinsey was sworn in as Mayor on July 1, 2013, the same day as her election. She resigned from her seat on the city council as part of the agreement to become mayor, which included the understanding that she would not stand in the mayoral election in November.[1] She instead ran to reclaim her former District 1 city council seat in the November 2013 election.[1] She was elected with only write-in opposition, and resumed her service as a regular council member in December 2013, while Patrick Cannon took office as Mayor.[3]