Painter's Folly was built by a wealthy local farmer named Samuel Painter in 1856, soon after he returned from travels in Europe. The house's ornate Italianate design inspired neighbors to brand it "Painter's Folly."[2] The three-story house spans 58,000 square feet and sits on a four-acre property adjoining the Brandywine Battlefield.[3]
Painter's nephew, Howard Pyle, rented the house as a summer residence, where for years he hosted Brandywine School artists' gatherings and mentored artists, including N. C. Wyeth. Wyeth's son, Andrew Wyeth, later depicted the house in several of his paintings, including Painter's Folly (1989) and Widow's Walk (1990).[4]