c. 1900 Meister began operating Otto Meister’s Nickelodeon Theater and Phanta-Phone dime museum.[1] In 1911 he built the Butterfly Theater on the site of the Nickelodeon, which was torn down in 1930 to make room for the Warner theater.[2][3] He partnered with John R. Freuler to create the Central Amusement Company which also controlled the Vaudette, the Atlas and the Climax Theaters in Milwaukee.[4]
The Butterfly opened on September 2, 1911; it became nationally known.[2][1] The theater opened to 1,500 people and showed several movies. A six-piece orchestra played and the Loos Brothers sang a duet called "My Hula Hula Love".[5]
Meister continued to own theaters in the Milwaukee area and he developed a reputation as being unfair to organized labor. In 1929 he was operating the White House Theatre when someone detonated a stick of dynamite against a wall of the building. Windows were blown out but damage was contained. The perpetrator was never found.[6]