Marist made their first regional tournament appearance in 2006 after losing in two games to UMass in the play-in round in 1996.[4][5] They faced Arizona in their first game, losing by a score of 9–0.[6] They were eliminated from the tournament after losing to Auburn by a score of 14–0, failing to score a run in their first NCAA Tournament appearance.[7]
The Red Foxes fell to the #1 ranked and eventual National Champion Oklahoma in their first game of the 2013 NCAA Tournament by a score of 17–0. Kyrsten Van Natta recorded the only hit of the game for the Red Foxes.[8] The Red Foxes were ultimately eliminated from the 2013 NCAA Tournament when they lost 5–3 to Fordham.[9]
In 2016, the Red Foxes returned to the NCAA tournament after a record-breaking season. With 45 wins, Marist set a new MAAC record for most wins in a single season.[10] The Red Foxes went on to play #13 ranked Tennessee in the Knoxville Regional.[11] The Red Foxes jumped out to a first inning lead on a two-run home run hit by Rebecca Freeman, however the Lady Vols scored 10 unanswered runs and defeated the Red Foxes by a score of 10–2.[12] Marist's time in the tournament came to an end after losing its second game of the regional to Ohio State by a final score of 6–1.[13]
In 2023, Marist qualified for their first NCAA tournament in seven years after defeating top-seeded Canisius in the MAAC championship game by a score of 2–1.[14][15] In their first game of the tournament, the team was no-hit by Florida State and lost via the mercy rule by a score of 9–0 in five innings.[16][17] The Red Foxes were eliminated from the tournament by South Carolina by a score of 2–1.[18][19]
National champion
Postseason invitational champion
Conference regular season champion
Conference regular season and conference tournament champion
Division regular season champion
Division regular season and conference tournament champion
Conference tournament champion