Law's Empire

Law's Empire
Cover of the first edition
AuthorRonald Dworkin
LanguageEnglish
SubjectJurisprudence
PublisherBelknap Press
Publication date
1986
Publication placeUnited States
Media typePrint
Pages470
ISBN9780674518353 (1st ed)
OCLC631282485

Law's Empire is a 1986 text in legal philosophy by Ronald Dworkin, in which the author continues his criticism of the philosophy of legal positivism as promoted by H.L.A. Hart during the middle to late 20th century. The book introduces Dworkin's Judge Hercules as an idealized version of a jurist with extraordinary legal skills who is able to challenge various predominating schools of legal interpretation and legal hermeneutics prominent throughout the 20th century.[1] Judge Hercules is eventually challenged by Judge Hermes, another idealized version of a jurist who is affected by an affinity to respecting historical legal meaning arguments which do not affect Judge Hercules in the same manner. Judge Hermes' theory of legal interpretation is found by Dworkin in the end to be inferior to the approach of Judge Hercules.

Background

Much of the twentieth century in legal philosophy has been characterized by the confrontation of legal positivism with natural law theory as being among the most prominent legal theories seen in the century. One major proponent of the Anglo-American version of legal positivism was H.L.A. Hart, a professor at Oxford University, who was a teacher of Dworkin's and with whom eventually Dworkin would come to strongly disagree. To challenge the prevailing schools of legal interpretation and legal philosophy in the late twentieth century, Dworkin invented the personage of Judge Hercules to represent a version of legal philosophy which he saw as effectively answering many of the shortcomings he had come to identify with Hart and other legal schools prominent in his time.

Dworkin's approach in the book is to present his argument in ten chapters with one summary chapter added at the end of the book titled, "Law Beyond Law". The book is original in its format compared to conventional approaches to academic studies in the law by introducing the personage of Judge Hercules early in the text to answer many of the legal theories which Dworkin wishes to discuss as to their being insufficient to meet the requirements of late 20th century jurisprudence. In Dworkin's perspective, the prevailing climate of legal theory at the end of the 20th century was understood by him as being represented by the deficiencies of many competing and contradictory legal theories being presented by the legal academy. The ten chapters of the book build their logical argument sequentially and in growing complexity of exposition where each chapter is dependent upon the logical demonstrations made in previous chapters in order to establish the rationale and comprehension at work in the mind of the legal personage represented by Judge Hercules.

Summary

Dworkin concisely states his primary concern in the preface of this volume concerning his approach to the philosophy of law: "We are subjects of law's empire, liegemen to its methods and ideals, bound in spirit while we debate what we must therefore do." The "empire" of the law is expansive for Dworkin and includes not only the domain of jurisprudence but extends fully into the domain of politics and sociology, including the philosophical domain of morals, ethics and even aesthetics as these affect the lives of all individuals of society.

Chapter One: What is Law?

In this chapter, Dworkin tells his readers that there are three types of law with which he is primarily concerned. These three areas of law are outlined as (a) Conventionalism, (b) Pragmatism (semantic theory), and (c) Law as integrity. Dworkin shall make a primary point of defending Law as integrity throughout the subsequent chapters of his text.

Chapter Two: Interpretive Concepts

Dworkin introduced his principle of the "semantic sting" of the semantic philosophy of law. He develops and distinguishes between two forms of skepticism to present his arguments differentiating between "internal skepticism" and "external skepticism", for use in subsequent chapters.

Chapter Three: Jurisprudence Revisited

Dworkin informs his readers that the concept of law is the theory of what forms the ground of law. The "concept of law" was used by H.L.A. Hart as the title for an approach to law strongly oriented to Anglo-American reading of positive law to which Dworkin would find insufficient for dealing with issues of jurisprudence encountered throughout the 20th century.

Chapter Four: Conventionalism

In this chapter, Dworkin begins his three-part, three-tier assessment of law with his criticism of Conventionalism. He differentiated Conventionalism as falling into two different kinds, which are insufficient, in the end, to the needs of contemporary jurisprudence at the end of the 20th century leading to the start of the 21st century. Dworkin ends the chapter asserting the failure of Conventionalism.

Chapter Five: Pragmatism and Personification

Dworkin rejects pragmatism here as insufficient to the adjudication requirements and legislative principles that he sees as prevailing at the end of the twentieth century. Dworkin begins to stress that contemporary jurisprudence in his view needs to hold in high esteem the values of justice as integrity, fairness, and due process.

Chapter Six: Integrity

For Dworkin, "Justice is a matter of outcomes: a political decision causes injustice, however fair its procedures that produced it, when it denies people some resource, liberty, or opportunity that the best theories of justice entitle them to have." For Dworkin, the answerability of jurisprudence to political theory and political obligations is central. Political ideals are presented as operating from a base of moral concerns that influence what is legislated as law.[2]

References

  1. ^ Guest, Stephen (2013). Ronald Dworkin (3rd ed.). Stanford Law Books. p. 83. ISBN 9780804784009. OCLC 823654726.
  2. ^ Dworkin, Ronald (1987). Law's Empire. Harvard University Press. p. 191.

Further reading

  • Allard, Julie. Dworkin et Kant: Réflexions sur le judgement. Bruxelles: Editions de l'ULB, 2001.
  • Brown, Alexander. Ronald Dworkin's Theory of Equality: Domestic and Global Perspectives. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.
  • Benjamin Brown, From Principles to Rules and from Musar to Halakhah - The Hafetz Hayim's Rulings on Libel and Gossip
  • Burke, John J.A. The Political Foundation of Law: The Need for Theory with Practical Value. San Francisco: Austin & Winfield, 1992.
  • Burley, Justine, ed. Dworkin and His Critics. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2004.
  • Cohen, Marshall, ed. Ronald Dworkin and Contemporary Jurisprudence. London: Duckworth, 1984.
  • Gaffney, Paul. Ronald Dworkin on Law as Integrity: Rights as Principles of Adjudication. Lewiston, New York: Mellen University Press, 1996.
  • Guest, Stephen. Ronald Dworkin (Jurists: Profiles in Legal Theory). Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2012.
  • Hershovitz, Scott, ed. Exploring Law's Empire: The Jurisprudence of Ronald Dworkin. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006.
  • Hunt, Alan, ed. Reading Dworkin Critically. New York: Berg, 1992.
  • Ripstein, Arthur, ed. Ronald Dworkin (Contemporary Philosophers in Focus). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.
  • Wesche, Stefen and Zanetti, Véronique, eds. Dworkin: Un débat. Paris: Ousia, 2000.

Read other articles:

Republik MaltaRepubblika ta' Malta (Malta)Republic of Malta (Inggris) Bendera Lambang Semboyan: Virtute et constantia (Latin: Moral dan Keteguhan)Lagu kebangsaan: L-Innu MaltiIbu kotaValletta35°53′42″N 14°30′36″E / 35.89500°N 14.51000°E / 35.89500; 14.51000Kota terbesarBirkirkara35°53′48″N 14°27′45″E / 35.89667°N 14.46250°E / 35.89667; 14.46250Bahasa resmiMalta dan InggrisPemerintahanRepublik parlementer• ...

ФонFons Країна  Франція Регіон Овернь-Рона-Альпи  Департамент Ардеш  Округ Ларжантьєр Кантон Обена Код INSEE 07091 Поштові індекси 07200 Координати 44°35′03″ пн. ш. 4°20′58″ сх. д.H G O Висота 232 - 492 м.н.р.м. Площа 4,03 км² Населення 328 (01-2020[1]) Густота 77,67 ос./км² Розміщен�...

هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (يونيو 2013) الفيوزين هو راسب فحمي متحجر تم تصنيفه - بعد جدل بين العلماء - كفحم حجري.[1] يتميز بقوام ليفي أسود اللون غير شفاف وغالبًا ما يحتفظ بتفاصيل بنية الجدار الخلوي.

Cogorno Entidad subnacional CogornoLocalización de Cogorno en Italia Coordenadas 44°19′59″N 9°22′21″E / 44.3330809, 9.3724611Capital CogornoIdioma oficial ItalianoEntidad Comuna de Italia • País Italia • Región Liguria • Provincia GénovaDirigentes   • Alcalde Enrica SommarivaFracciones Breccanecca, Costa, Monticelli, Panesi, San Salvatore (sede comunal)Municipios limítrofes Carasco, Chiavari, Lavagna, NeSuperficie   •...

تريكسي ووراك معلومات شخصية الميلاد 28 سبتمبر 1981 (العمر 42 سنة)كوتبوس، ألمانيا الشرقية الطول 160 سنتيمتر  الجنسية  ألمانيا الوزن 50 كيلوغرام  الحياة العملية الفرق كانيون–إس آر إيه إم  [لغات أخرى]‏ (2012–2018)  المهنة دراجة  نوع السباق سباق الدراجات على الطريق ...

Verdon Entidad subnacional VerdonLocalización de Verdon en Francia Coordenadas 48°56′56″N 3°37′17″E / 48.948888888889, 3.6213888888889Entidad Comuna de Francia • País Francia • Región Champaña-Ardenas • Departamento Marne • Distrito distrito de Épernay • Cantón cantón de Montmirail • Mancomunidad Communauté de communes de la Brie ChampenoiseAlcalde Rosemonde Roullot(2008 - 2014)Superficie   • Total 11.39 k...

Maurice Bavaud Maurice Bavaud (* 15. Januar 1916 in Neuenburg, Schweiz; † 14. Mai 1941 in Berlin-Plötzensee; heimatberechtigt in Bottens) war ein Schweizer Seminarist, der versuchte, Adolf Hitler am 9. November 1938 in München zu erschiessen. Der Anschlag auf Hitler scheiterte. Nach seiner Festnahme wurde Bavaud in einem Geheimprozess vom Volksgerichtshof zum Tode verurteilt und hingerichtet. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Leben 1.1 Kindheit und Ausbildung 1.2 Versuchter Anschlag auf Hitler 1.3 In ...

خافيير سافيولا Javier Saviola معلومات شخصية الميلاد 11 ديسمبر 1981 (العمر 41 سنة)بيونس آيرس، الأرجنتين الطول 1.68 م (5 قدم 6 بوصة) مركز اللعب مهاجم الجنسية أرجنتيني اللقب الأرنب معلومات النادي النادي الحالي برشلونة للشباب (مساعد) FC Encamp [الإنجليزية]‏ (futsal) مسيرة الشباب سنوات فر

American sportscaster Samantha PonderPonder reporting for Fox College Sports at Jack Trice Stadium in October 2010BornSamantha Sainte-Claire Steele (1985-12-11) December 11, 1985 (age 37)Phoenix, Arizona, U.S.Alma materThe King’s CollegeLiberty UniversityOccupationESPN Sunday NFL Countdown hostYears active2006–presentSpouse Christian Ponder ​(m. 2012)​Children3 Samantha Ponder (née Steele;[1] born December 11, 1985) is an American sport...

██ Thành viên đầy đủ của ASEAN██ Quan sát viên ASEAN██ Ứng cử viên thành viên ASEAN██ ASEAN+3███ Hội nghị cấp cao Đông Á██████ Diễn đàn Khu vực ASEAN Sự mở rộng của Hiệp hội các quốc gia Đông Nam Á[1] là quá trình mở rộng Hiệp hội các quốc gia Đông Nam Á (ASEAN) thông qua việc kết nạp các quốc gia thành viên mới. Quá trình này bắt đầu từ khi năm thành viên ...

City in Iowa, USANew Liberty, IowaCityLocation of New Liberty, IowaCoordinates: 41°43′2″N 90°52′46″W / 41.71722°N 90.87944°W / 41.71722; -90.87944CountryUSAState IowaCountyScottArea[1] • City0.09 sq mi (0.23 km2) • Land0.09 sq mi (0.23 km2) • Water0.00 sq mi (0.00 km2)Elevation797 ft (243 m)Population (2020) • City138 • Densit...

Aircraft involved in 1983 landing accident Turkish Airlines Flight 158The aircraft involved in the accident, 1981.AccidentDate16 January 1983SummaryRunway undershot in bad weather conditionsSitenear Ankara Esenboğa Airport, Turkey 40°06′46.8″N 32°58′48″E / 40.113000°N 32.98000°E / 40.113000; 32.98000AircraftAircraft typeBoeing 727-2F2Aircraft nameAfyonOperatorTurkish AirlinesRegistrationTC-JBRFlight originOrly Airport, Paris, FranceStopoverIstanb...

2013 video game 2013 video gameStar TrekCover art featuring Spock (left) and KirkDeveloper(s)Digital ExtremesPublisher(s)Bandai Namco EntertainmentWriter(s)Marianne KrawczykComposer(s)Chad SeiterPlatform(s)PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, Microsoft WindowsReleaseNA: April 23, 2013EU: April 26, 2013Genre(s)Action-adventure, third-person shooterMode(s)Single-player, multiplayer Star Trek is a third-person action-adventure Star Trek video game. It was developed by Digital Extremes and co-published by Ba...

2003 studio album by Bret MichaelsSongs of LifeStudio album by Bret MichaelsReleasedApril 22, 2003[1]GenreHard rockLength46:40LabelPoor BoyBret Michaels chronology A Letter from Death Row(1998) Songs of Life(2003) Freedom of Sound(2005) Singles from Songs of Life RaineReleased: 2003 BittersweetReleased: 2003 Songs of Life is the debut solo studio album by American musician Bret Michaels, lead singer of the rock band Poison. The album was released April 22, 2003 and coincides w...

Artikel atau sebagian dari artikel ini mungkin diterjemahkan dari Hispanic di en.wikipedia.org. Isinya masih belum akurat, karena bagian yang diterjemahkan masih perlu diperhalus dan disempurnakan. Jika Anda menguasai bahasa aslinya, harap pertimbangkan untuk menelusuri referensinya dan menyempurnakan terjemahan ini. Anda juga dapat ikut bergotong royong pada ProyekWiki Perbaikan Terjemahan. (Pesan ini dapat dihapus jika terjemahan dirasa sudah cukup tepat. Lihat pula: panduan penerjemahan ar...

Fijian rugby union player (born 1984) Rugby playerVereniki GonevaGoneva in 2014Birth nameVereniki GonevaDate of birth (1984-04-05) 5 April 1984 (age 39)Place of birthLautoka, FijiHeight5.9 ft (1.79 m)Weight102 kg (16 st 1 lb; 225 lb)SpouseRaijeli KatalauRugby union careerPosition(s) Wing, Centre, FullbackCurrent team Mont-de-MarsanSenior careerYears Team Apps (Points)2009–2011 US Colomiers 46 (28)2011–2012 Tarbes 19 (40)2012–2016 Leicester Tigers 89 (2...

Subway line in Gyeongsangnam-do and Busan, South Korea This article does not cite any sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Busan Metro Line 2 – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (December 2009) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Line 2 OverviewNative name2호선(2號線)I HoseonStatusOperationalTerminiJangsan or J...

The Muppets discographyStudio albums16Compilation albums4Music videos5EPs2Singles8Other appearances2 The discography of the Muppets, an American puppet ensemble group originally created by Jim Henson, includes of sixteen studio albums, four compilation albums, one extended play, eight singles, two featured artist singles and five music videos. Of the studio and compilation albums, three are soundtracks from seasons of The Muppet Show and seven of eight motion pictures. The soundtrack to the s...

British politician (1852–1936) Robert Cunninghame GrahamCunninghame Graham, c. 1890.1st President of the Scottish National PartyIn office7 April 1934 – 20 March 1936Preceded byPosition createdSucceeded byRoland MuirheadPresident of the Scottish Labour PartyIn office25 August 1888 – 1895Preceded byPosition createdSucceeded byParty DisestablishedMP for North West LanarkshireIn office1886–1892Preceded byJohn BairdSucceeded byGraeme Alexander Lockhart WhitelawMajority332...

Japanese manga series and its adaptation(s) Fist of the Blue SkyCover of volume 22, featuring most of the main characters.蒼天の拳(Sōten no Ken) MangaWritten byTetsuo HaraSupervision:BuronsonIllustrated byTetsuo HaraPublished byShinchoshaEnglish publisherNA: Gutsoon! Entertainment (canceled)MagazineWeekly Comic BunchEnglish magazineNA: Raijin ComicsDemographicSeinenOriginal runMay 2001 – August 2010Volumes22 (List of volumes) Anime television seriesDirected byYoshih...