Law's Empire

Law's Empire
Cover of the first edition
AuthorRonald Dworkin
LanguageEnglish
SubjectJurisprudence
PublisherBelknap Press
Publication date
1986
Publication placeUnited States
Media typePrint
Pages470
ISBN9780674518353 (1st ed)
OCLC631282485

Law's Empire is a 1986 text in legal philosophy by Ronald Dworkin, in which the author continues his criticism of the philosophy of legal positivism as promoted by H.L.A. Hart during the middle to late 20th century. The book introduces Dworkin's Judge Hercules as an idealized version of a jurist with extraordinary legal skills who is able to challenge various predominating schools of legal interpretation and legal hermeneutics prominent throughout the 20th century.[1] Judge Hercules is eventually challenged by Judge Hermes, another idealized version of a jurist who is affected by an affinity to respecting historical legal meaning arguments which do not affect Judge Hercules in the same manner. Judge Hermes' theory of legal interpretation is found by Dworkin in the end to be inferior to the approach of Judge Hercules.

Background

Much of the twentieth century in legal philosophy has been characterized by the confrontation of legal positivism with natural law theory as being among the most prominent legal theories seen in the century. One major proponent of the Anglo-American version of legal positivism was H.L.A. Hart, a professor at Oxford University, who was a teacher of Dworkin's and with whom eventually Dworkin would come to strongly disagree. To challenge the prevailing schools of legal interpretation and legal philosophy in the late twentieth century, Dworkin invented the personage of Judge Hercules to represent a version of legal philosophy which he saw as effectively answering many of the shortcomings he had come to identify with Hart and other legal schools prominent in his time.

Dworkin's approach in the book is to present his argument in ten chapters with one summary chapter added at the end of the book titled, "Law Beyond Law". The book is original in its format compared to conventional approaches to academic studies in the law by introducing the personage of Judge Hercules early in the text to answer many of the legal theories which Dworkin wishes to discuss as to their being insufficient to meet the requirements of late 20th century jurisprudence. In Dworkin's perspective, the prevailing climate of legal theory at the end of the 20th century was understood by him as being represented by the deficiencies of many competing and contradictory legal theories being presented by the legal academy. The ten chapters of the book build their logical argument sequentially and in growing complexity of exposition where each chapter is dependent upon the logical demonstrations made in previous chapters in order to establish the rationale and comprehension at work in the mind of the legal personage represented by Judge Hercules.

Summary

Dworkin concisely states his primary concern in the preface of this volume concerning his approach to the philosophy of law: "We are subjects of law's empire, liegemen to its methods and ideals, bound in spirit while we debate what we must therefore do." The "empire" of the law is expansive for Dworkin and includes not only the domain of jurisprudence but extends fully into the domain of politics and sociology, including the philosophical domain of morals, ethics and even aesthetics as these affect the lives of all individuals of society.

Chapter One: What is Law?

In this chapter, Dworkin tells his readers that there are three types of law with which he is primarily concerned. These three areas of law are outlined as (a) Conventionalism, (b) Pragmatism (semantic theory), and (c) Law as integrity. Dworkin shall make a primary point of defending Law as integrity throughout the subsequent chapters of his text.

Chapter Two: Interpretive Concepts

Dworkin introduced his principle of the "semantic sting" of the semantic philosophy of law. He develops and distinguishes between two forms of skepticism to present his arguments differentiating between "internal skepticism" and "external skepticism", for use in subsequent chapters.

Chapter Three: Jurisprudence Revisited

Dworkin informs his readers that the concept of law is the theory of what forms the ground of law. The "concept of law" was used by H.L.A. Hart as the title for an approach to law strongly oriented to Anglo-American reading of positive law to which Dworkin would find insufficient for dealing with issues of jurisprudence encountered throughout the 20th century.

Chapter Four: Conventionalism

In this chapter, Dworkin begins his three-part, three-tier assessment of law with his criticism of Conventionalism. He differentiated Conventionalism as falling into two different kinds, which are insufficient, in the end, to the needs of contemporary jurisprudence at the end of the 20th century leading to the start of the 21st century. Dworkin ends the chapter asserting the failure of Conventionalism.

Chapter Five: Pragmatism and Personification

Dworkin rejects pragmatism here as insufficient to the adjudication requirements and legislative principles that he sees as prevailing at the end of the twentieth century. Dworkin begins to stress that contemporary jurisprudence in his view needs to hold in high esteem the values of justice as integrity, fairness, and due process.

Chapter Six: Integrity

For Dworkin, "Justice is a matter of outcomes: a political decision causes injustice, however fair its procedures that produced it, when it denies people some resource, liberty, or opportunity that the best theories of justice entitle them to have." For Dworkin, the answerability of jurisprudence to political theory and political obligations is central. Political ideals are presented as operating from a base of moral concerns that influence what is legislated as law.[2]

References

  1. ^ Guest, Stephen (2013). Ronald Dworkin (3rd ed.). Stanford Law Books. p. 83. ISBN 9780804784009. OCLC 823654726.
  2. ^ Dworkin, Ronald (1987). Law's Empire. Harvard University Press. p. 191.

Further reading

  • Allard, Julie. Dworkin et Kant: Réflexions sur le judgement. Bruxelles: Editions de l'ULB, 2001.
  • Brown, Alexander. Ronald Dworkin's Theory of Equality: Domestic and Global Perspectives. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.
  • Benjamin Brown, From Principles to Rules and from Musar to Halakhah - The Hafetz Hayim's Rulings on Libel and Gossip
  • Burke, John J.A. The Political Foundation of Law: The Need for Theory with Practical Value. San Francisco: Austin & Winfield, 1992.
  • Burley, Justine, ed. Dworkin and His Critics. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2004.
  • Cohen, Marshall, ed. Ronald Dworkin and Contemporary Jurisprudence. London: Duckworth, 1984.
  • Gaffney, Paul. Ronald Dworkin on Law as Integrity: Rights as Principles of Adjudication. Lewiston, New York: Mellen University Press, 1996.
  • Guest, Stephen. Ronald Dworkin (Jurists: Profiles in Legal Theory). Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2012.
  • Hershovitz, Scott, ed. Exploring Law's Empire: The Jurisprudence of Ronald Dworkin. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006.
  • Hunt, Alan, ed. Reading Dworkin Critically. New York: Berg, 1992.
  • Ripstein, Arthur, ed. Ronald Dworkin (Contemporary Philosophers in Focus). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.
  • Wesche, Stefen and Zanetti, Véronique, eds. Dworkin: Un débat. Paris: Ousia, 2000.

Read other articles:

Uğur Boral Informasi pribadiNama lengkap Uğur BoralTanggal lahir 14 April 1982 (umur 41)Tempat lahir İstanbul, TurkiTinggi 1,77 m (5 ft 9+1⁄2 in)Posisi bermain Bek kiriInformasi klubKlub saat ini SamsunsporNomor 25Karier senior*Tahun Tim Tampil (Gol)2000–2006 Gençlerbirliği 85 (21)2001–2002 → Kocaelispor (pinjaman) 21 (2)2003–2004 → Ankaraspor (pinjaman) 0 (0)2006–2012 Fenerbahçe 79 (7)2012– Samsunspor 6 (1)Tim nasional‡2005– Turki 11 (1) * P...

 

Futari wa Pretty Cure Splash StarGenreAksi, Komedi, Shōjo AnimeSutradaraToshiaki KomuraStudioToei AnimationTayang 5 Februari 2006 – 28 Januari 2007 AnimeFutari wa Pretty Cure Splash Star the Movie: Tick-Tock Crisis Hanging by a Thin Thread!SutradaraAtsuji ShimizuStudioToei AnimationTayang 9 Desember 2006  Portal anime dan manga Futari wa Pretty Cure Splash Star (ふたりはプリキュア スプラッシュ☆スターcode: ja is deprecated , Futari wa Purikyua Supurasshu Sutā) ...

 

Benin Golf Air IATA ICAO Kode panggil A8 BGL BENIN GOLF Didirikan2002PenghubungCotonouKantor pusatCotonou, BeninSitus webhttp://www.benin-golf-air.com Benin Golf Air merupakan sebuah maskapai penerbangan yang berbasis di Cotonou, Benin. Maskapai ini diresmikan dan memulai operasinya pada 2002 dan mengoperasikan penerbangan regional di Afrika Barat. Basis utamanya terletak di bandar Udara Cadjehoun, Cotonou.[1] Destinasi Benin Golf Air mengoperasikan penerbangan regional dari Cotonou m...

Ологойская битваОсновной конфликт: Первая ойрато-маньчжурская война Дата 21 июля 1690 года Место озеро Ологой, Халха Итог Победа Джунгарского ханства Противники Джунгарское ханство Империя Цин Командующие Галдан-Бошогту Арани Силы сторон 20 000—25 000 чел. (кавалерия, спешенн�...

 

Public interest design is a human-centered[1] and participatory design practice[2] that places emphasis on the “triple bottom line” of sustainable design that includes ecological, economic, and social issues and on designing products, structures, and systems that address issues such as economic development and the preservation of the environment. Projects incorporating public interest design focus on the general good of the local citizens with a fundamentally collaborative...

 

UroniWyandot o WendatCapo tribù Urone, 1909 Nomi alternativiUroni-Wendant Luogo d'origineLago Ontario, Georgian Bay LinguaLingua wyandot, lingua irochese, inglese, francese ReligioneTotemismo, protestantesimo, cattolicesimo Gruppi correlatiPetuni Distribuzione  Canada[1](Québec)4.410 Stati Uniti(Kansas, Michigan, Oklahoma)5.900 Manuale Gli Uroni (in inglese ed in francese Hurons) o Uroni-Wendant (in lingua wyandot: Wyandot o Wendat), sono un gruppo etni...

TransJakartaInfoWilayahJakarta, IndonesiaJenisAngkutan cepat busJumlah jalur14 (beroperasi), 5 (rencana)Jumlah stasiunlebih dari 200Penumpang hariansekitar 350.000 penumpangOperasiDimulai15 Januari 2004OperatorPT. Transportasi JakartaTeknisPanjang sistem172kmLebar sepurJalur bus Daftar koridor Transjakarta adalah daftar rute yang dioperasikan oleh sistem angkutan cepat massal Transjakarta. Secara garis besar, terdapat dua jenis rute, yakni Rute Reguler BRT (Bus Rapid Transit) dan Reguler Non-...

 

24th episode of the 7th season of The Mary Tyler Moore Show The Last ShowThe Mary Tyler Moore Show episodeThe station crew's poignant farewellEpisode no.Season 7Episode 24Directed byJay SandrichWritten byJames L. Brooks, Allan Burns, Ed Weinberger, Stan Daniels, David Lloyd and Bob EllisonOriginal air datesMarch 18, 1977 (1977-03-18) (Canada) March 19, 1977 (1977-03-19) (US)Guest appearances Valerie Harper (Rhoda) Cloris Leachman (Phyllis) Robbie Rist (David...

 

Сельское поселение России (МО 2-го уровня)Новотитаровское сельское поселение Флаг[d] Герб 45°14′09″ с. ш. 38°58′16″ в. д.HGЯO Страна  Россия Субъект РФ Краснодарский край Район Динской Включает 4 населённых пункта Адм. центр Новотитаровская Глава сельского пос�...

Ban Bí thư Ủy ban Trung ương Đảng Cộng sản Trung Quốc 中国共产党中央书记处Vị thế pháp lýĐiều hành Đảng Cộng sản cùng với Bộ Chính trị Đảng Cộng sản Trung QuốcTrụ sở chínhTrung Nam HảiVị tríBắc Kinh, Trung QuốcThành viên 7Đứng đầuThành viênThái Kỳ,Ủy viên Thường vụ Bộ Chính trịChịu trách nhiệm trướcBộ Chính trị Đảng Cộng sản Trung QuốcBầu bởiBan chấp hành Trung ương...

 

AlkibiadesAlkibiades diajarkan oleh Socrates (1776) oleh François-André VincentLahirskt. 450 SMAthena klasikMeninggal404 SMGunung Elafos, Frigia, Kekaisaran AkhemeniyahPengabdianAthena(415–412 SM Sparta) (412–411 SM Persia)PangkatJenderal (Strategos)Perang/pertempuranPertempuran Abydos (410 SM)Pertempuran Cyzicus (410 SM)Pengepungan Byzantium (408 SM) Alkibiades, putra Kleinias, dari deme Scambonidae (/ˌælsɪˈbaɪ.ədiːz/;[1] Bahasa Yunani: Ἀλκιβιάδης Κλεινί...

 

Tampa Bay Buccaneers Musim saat iniDidirikan 24 April 1974; 50 tahun lalu (24 April 1974)[1]Musim pertama: 1976Bermain di Raymond James StadiumTampa, FloridaKantor pusat di Bermarkas di One Buccaneer PlaceTampa, Florida Tampa Bay Buccaneers logoTampa Bay Buccaneers wordmarkLogoWordmarkAfiliasi liga National Football League (1976–sekarang) American Football Conference (1976) Divisi Barat AFC (1976) National Football Conference (1977–sekarang) Divisi Tengah NFC (1977–2001...

В Википедии есть статьи о других людях с фамилией Флеминг. Францис Филип Флеминг 15-й губернатор Флориды 8 января 1889 — 3 января 1893 Предшественник Эдвард Перри Преемник Henry L. Mitchell Рождение 28 сентября 1841(1841-09-28)Панама-Парк, Дувол, Флорида Смерть 20 декабря 1908(1908-12-20) (67 лет)Джэк...

 

Voce principale: Associazione Sportiva Cittadella. A.S. CittadellaStagione 2016-2017Sport calcio Squadra Cittadella Allenatore Roberto Venturato All. in seconda Edoardo Gorini Presidente Andrea Gabrielli Direttore generale Stefano Marchetti Serie B6º posto Play-offTurno preliminare Coppa ItaliaSecondo turno Maggiori presenzeCampionato: Alfonso (41+1)Totale: Alfonso (42) Miglior marcatoreCampionato: Litteri (13)Totale: Litteri (13) StadioPiercesare Tombolato (7.623) Abbonati1 835 Maggio...

 

French-American mathematician (1924–2010) See also: Mandelbrot set Benoit[n 1] MandelbrotMandelbrot at a TED conference in 2010Born(1924-11-20)20 November 1924Warsaw, PolandDied14 October 2010(2010-10-14) (aged 85)Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S.NationalityFrenchAmericanPolishAlma materÉcole PolytechniqueCalifornia Institute of TechnologyUniversity of ParisKnown forMandelbrot setChaos theoryFractalsZipf–Mandelbrot lawSpouse(s)Aliette Kagan(m. 1955–2010; his death)A...

Literature-related events in France during the 19th century This article relies largely or entirely on a single source. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please help improve this article by introducing citations to additional sources.Find sources: 19th-century French literature – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (November 2017) French Language and Literature Authors • Lit categories French literary history Medieval 16th ce...

 

Para la terminal ferroviaria, véase Estación Puente Alsina. Para la batalla de 1880, véase Batalla de Puente Alsina. Para la película argentina dirigida por José Agustín Ferreyra en 1935, véase Puente Alsina (película). Puente Ezequiel Demonty (ex Puente Alsina) Patrimonio Cultural de Buenos Aires El puente, popularmente llamado Alsina, sobre el RiachueloUbicaciónPaís  ArgentinaLocalidad Buenos AiresValentín AlsinaUbicación Nueva Pompeya y Valentín AlsinaCoordenadas 34°39�...

 

Bishop of Munster For the British company, see Ludger Limited. For other people, see Ludger (name). SaintLudgerSaint Ludger from an illuminated manuscriptApostle of SaxonyBornc. 742Zuilen near Utrecht, FranciaDied26 March 809 (aged 66–67)Billerbeck, Duchy of SaxonyVenerated inOrthodox ChurchRoman Catholic ChurchFeast26 MarchAttributesBishop holding a cathedral; reciting his Breviary; with a swan on either sidePatronageGroningen, Netherlands, Deventer, Netherlands; East Frisia;...

Wide range of activities that indicate student dissatisfaction School strike redirects here. For climate-related schools strikes, see School Strike for Climate. This article may contain unverified or indiscriminate information in embedded lists. Please help clean up the lists by removing items or incorporating them into the text of the article. (August 2022) The examples and perspective in this article deal primarily with the United States and Western culture and do not represent a worldwide ...

 

Hong Kong singer and actor In this Hong Kong name, the surname is Chan. In accordance with Hong Kong custom, the Western-style name is Eason Chan and the Chinese-style name is Chan Yick Shun. Eason Chan陳奕迅Chan in 2018Born (1974-07-27) 27 July 1974 (age 50)British Hong KongAlma materKingston UniversityRoyal Academy of MusicOccupationsSingeractorYears active1995–presentSpouse Hilary Tsui ​(m. 2006)​Children1Musical careerAlso known asGod of E ...