Beginning in 2008, the Knights began competing in football in the Mid-South Conference (MSC). In their first football season, the Knights would finish 1–9 overall, with no conference games played. The Knights were coached by Dane Damron, in his only season as head coach in Mid-South Conference play. The Knight sole win – and first win in school history – would come against Trinity Bible College by a score of 50–6.[2] Damron would leave at the end of the 2008 season for Virginia-Wise Highland as a strength and conditioning coach.
The Knights would hire former assistant Morehead State coach Zack Moore[3] to replace Damron, beginning in the 2009 season. Moore would coach the Knights for two seasons, finishing with an overall record of 1–21; the Knights would finish sixth and seventh in their conference, each year respectively. Following the culmination of the 2010 season, Kentucky Christian University (KCU) Athletics would relieve Moore of his head coaching duties.
Following the 2010 season, KCU Athletics would hire former NFLwide receiverMike Furrey, as the new head coach for the Knights.[4] Furrey would lead the Knights to their best overall season record of 7–4 during the 2012 season; he would finish his two-year tenure as head coach with an 11–11 overall record. Furrey would resign his position as Knights head coach on February 20, 2013, to become wide receivers coach for Marshall University.[5]
After the departure of Furrey in early 2013, the Knights would hire former Fleming County High School head coach Gene Peterson to the same position with KCU starting in the 2013 season.[6] Peterson would compile an 8–14 overall record in two years as head coach. Peterson would leave KCU following the 2014 season.[7]
KCU Athletics would then hire former McKendree Bearcatsdefensive coordinator Steve Barrows as the new head coach for the 2015 season. During Barrows' two-year tenure with the Knights, he finished with an 8–14 overall record.[7]
Built for the Knights to begin their play at the start of the 2008 season, KCU field was constructed by funds from the university. The stadium utilizes a turf field and has a capacity of 1,000.[9]