He has written articles for publications ranging from Rolling Stone to the ABA Journal and is author of the book Archibald Cox: The Conscience of a Nation. An expert on the constitutional crisis presented by Watergate, he has also published legal commentary on privacy issues.[8] In 2006, he testified before the U.S. Senate regarding warrantless surveillance.[9] His most recent book, The Death of American Virtue: Clinton vs. Starr, was released on February 16, 2010.[10]
Gormley was nominated by Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf to one of two vacancies on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in February 2015. The Pennsylvania State Senate opted not to fill the vacancies, instead allowing the seats to be filled in the November election.[11]
On November 4, 2015, Duquesne University announced that Gormley would be the 13th President of Duquesne University, following the retirement of Charles J. Dougherty, effective July 1, 2016.[12]
In October 2021, Gormley published his first novel, a legal thriller entitled The Heiress of Pittsburgh. He has described the novel as a "love story to Pittsburgh".[13]