Larry Flick from Billboard wrote that the song "is a direct descendent of "Gonna Make You Sweat", stating that "this pleasing track has all of the rousing gospel elements required to fill dancefloors".[2] He added that "this jam is etched with more of a streetwise vibe. Rapper Q-Unique runs lyrical rings around the now-departed Freedom Williams, and Deborah Cooper proves to be a well-seasoned belter."[3] John Martinucci from the Gavin Report commented, "Though the Music Factory has had personnel changes, the technical aspects of the group don't miss a beat. Rapper Q-Unique and vocalist Deborah Cooper sound comfortable in their new surroundings".[4]
Track listings
US 12-inch vinyl
A1. "Keep It Comin' (Dance Till You Can't Dance No More)" (C&C club mix)
A2. "Keep It Comin' (Dance Till You Can't Dance No More)" (Straight Outta Da Bronx mix)
B1. "Keep It Comin' (Dance Till You Can't Dance No More)" (The Cole & Clivilles house anthem)
B2. "Keep It Comin' (Dance Till You Can't Dance No More)" (A Capella Pieces)
CD single
"Keep It Comin' (Dance Till You Can't Dance No More)" (pop radio mix)
"Keep It Comin' (Dance Till You Can't Dance No More)" (radio mix)
"Keep It Comin' (Dance Till You Can't Dance No More)" (extended mix)