Kaktovik numerals

The 20 digits of the Kaktovik system

The Kaktovik numerals or Kaktovik Iñupiaq numerals[1] are a base-20 system of numerical digits created by Alaskan Iñupiat. They are visually iconic, with shapes that indicate the number being represented.

The Iñupiaq language has a base-20 numeral system, as do the other Eskimo–Aleut languages of Alaska and Canada (and formerly Greenland). Arabic numerals, which were designed for a base-10 system, are inadequate for Iñupiaq and other Inuit languages. To remedy this problem, students in Kaktovik, Alaska, invented a base-20 numeral notation in 1994, which has spread among the Alaskan Iñupiat and has been considered for use in Canada.

System

Iñupiaq, like other Inuit languages, has a base-20 counting system with a sub-base of 5 (a quinary-vigesimal system). That is, quantities are counted in scores (as in Welsh and French quatre-vingts 'eighty'), with intermediate numerals for 5, 10, and 15. Thus 78 is identified as three score fifteen-three.[2]

The Kaktovik digits graphically reflect the lexical structure of the Iñupiaq numbering system.[3]

The twenty digits
0 𝋀 kisitchisaġvik 5 𝋅 tallimat 10 𝋊 qulit 15 𝋏 akimiaq
1 𝋁 atausiq 6 𝋆 itchaksrat 11 𝋋 qulit atausiq 16 𝋐 akimiaq atausiq
2 𝋂 malġuk 7 𝋇 tallimat malġuk 12 𝋌 qulit malġuk 17 𝋑 akimiaq malġuk
3 𝋃 piŋasut 8 𝋈 tallimat piŋasut 13 𝋍 qulit piŋasut 18 𝋒 akimiaq piŋasut
4 𝋄 sisamat 9 𝋉 quliŋŋuġutaiḷaq 14 𝋎 akimiaġutaiḷaq 19 𝋓 iñuiññaġutaiḷaq

Larger numbers are composed of these digits in a positional notation:

Decimal Vigesimal
Arabic Arabic Kaktovik
20 1020 𝋁𝋀
40 2020 𝋂𝋀
400 10020 𝋁𝋀𝋀
800 20020 𝋂𝋀𝋀

Values

In the following table are the decimal values of the Kaktovik digits up to three places to the left and to the right of the units' place.[3]

Decimal values of Kaktovik numbers
n n × 203 n × 202 n × 201 n × 200 n × 20−1 n × 20−2 n × 20−3
1 𝋁,𝋀𝋀𝋀
8,000
𝋁𝋀𝋀
400
𝋁𝋀
20
𝋁
1
𝋀.𝋁
0.05
𝋀.𝋀𝋁
0.0025
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋁
0.000125
2 𝋂,𝋀𝋀𝋀
16,000
𝋂𝋀𝋀
800
𝋂𝋀
40
𝋂
2
𝋀.𝋂
0.1
𝋀.𝋀𝋂
0.005
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋂
0.00025
3 𝋃,𝋀𝋀𝋀
24,000
𝋃𝋀𝋀
1,200
𝋃𝋀
60
𝋃
3
𝋀.𝋃
0.15
𝋀.𝋀𝋃
0.0075
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋃
0.000375
4 𝋄,𝋀𝋀𝋀
32,000
𝋄𝋀𝋀
1,600
𝋄𝋀
80
𝋄
4
𝋀.𝋄
0.2
𝋀.𝋀𝋄
0.01
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋄
0.0005
5 𝋅,𝋀𝋀𝋀
40,000
𝋅𝋀𝋀
2,000
𝋅𝋀
100
𝋅
5
𝋀.𝋅
0.25
𝋀.𝋀𝋅
0.0125
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋅
0.000625
6 𝋆,𝋀𝋀𝋀
48,000
𝋆𝋀𝋀
2,400
𝋆𝋀
120
𝋆
6
𝋀.𝋆
0.3
𝋀.𝋀𝋆
0.015
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋆
0.00075
7 𝋇,𝋀𝋀𝋀
56,000
𝋇𝋀𝋀
2,800
𝋇𝋀
140
𝋇
7
𝋀.𝋇
0.35
𝋀.𝋀𝋇
0.0175
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋇
0.000875
8 𝋈,𝋀𝋀𝋀
64,000
𝋈𝋀𝋀
3,200
𝋈𝋀
160
𝋈
8
𝋀.𝋈
0.4
𝋀.𝋀𝋈
0.02
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋈
0.001
9 𝋉,𝋀𝋀𝋀
72,000
𝋉𝋀𝋀
3,600
𝋉𝋀
180
𝋉
9
𝋀.𝋉
0.45
𝋀.𝋀𝋉
0.0225
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋉
0.001125
10 𝋊,𝋀𝋀𝋀
80,000
𝋊𝋀𝋀
4,000
𝋊𝋀
200
𝋊
10
𝋀.𝋊
0.5
𝋀.𝋀𝋊
0.025
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋊
0.00125
11 𝋋,𝋀𝋀𝋀
88,000
𝋋𝋀𝋀
4,400
𝋋𝋀
220
𝋋
11
𝋀.𝋋
0.55
𝋀.𝋀𝋋
0.0275
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋋
0.001375
12 𝋌,𝋀𝋀𝋀
96,000
𝋌𝋀𝋀
4,800
𝋌𝋀
240
𝋌
12
𝋀.𝋌
0.6
𝋀.𝋀𝋌
0.03
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋌
0.0015
13 𝋍,𝋀𝋀𝋀
104,000
𝋍𝋀𝋀
5,200
𝋍𝋀
260
𝋍
13
𝋀.𝋍
0.65
𝋀.𝋀𝋍
0.0325
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋍
0.001625
14 𝋎,𝋀𝋀𝋀
112,000
𝋎𝋀𝋀
5,600
𝋎𝋀
280
𝋎
14
𝋀.𝋎
0.7
𝋀.𝋀𝋎
0.035
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋎
0.00175
15 𝋏,𝋀𝋀𝋀
120,000
𝋏𝋀𝋀
6,000
𝋏𝋀
300
𝋏
15
𝋀.𝋏
0.75
𝋀.𝋀𝋏
0.0375
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋏
0.001875
16 𝋐,𝋀𝋀𝋀
128,000
𝋐𝋀𝋀
6,400
𝋐𝋀
320
𝋐
16
𝋀.𝋐
0.8
𝋀.𝋀𝋐
0.04
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋐
0.002
17 𝋑,𝋀𝋀𝋀
136,000
𝋑𝋀𝋀
6,800
𝋑𝋀
340
𝋑
17
𝋀.𝋑
0.85
𝋀.𝋀𝋑
0.0425
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋑
0.002125
18 𝋒,𝋀𝋀𝋀
144,000
𝋒𝋀𝋀
7,200
𝋒𝋀
360
𝋒
18
𝋀.𝋒
0.9
𝋀.𝋀𝋒
0.045
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋒
0.00225
19 𝋓,𝋀𝋀𝋀
152,000
𝋓𝋀𝋀
7,600
𝋓𝋀
380
𝋓
19
𝋀.𝋓
0.95
𝋀.𝋀𝋓
0.0475
𝋀.𝋀𝋀𝋓
0.002375

Origin

Map of Alaska highlighting North Slope Borough, part of Iñupiat Nunaat

The numerals began as an enrichment activity in 1994, when, during a math class exploring binary numbers at Harold Kaveolook middle school on Barter Island Kaktovik, Alaska,[4] students noted that their language used a base-20 system.

They found that, when they tried to write numbers or do arithmetic with Arabic numerals, they did not have enough symbols to represent the Iñupiaq numbers.[5]

They first addressed this lack by creating ten extra symbols, but found these were difficult to remember. The small middle school had only nine students so the entire school was able to work together to create a base-20 notation. Their teacher, William Bartley, guided them.[5]

After brainstorming, the students came up with several qualities that an ideal system would have:

  1. Visual simplicity: The symbols should be "easy to remember."
  2. Iconicity: There should be a "clear relationship between the symbols and their meanings."
  3. Efficiency: It should be "easy to write" the symbols, and they should be able to be "written quickly" without lifting the pencil from the paper.
  4. Distinctiveness: They should "look very different from Arabic numerals," so there would not be any confusion between notation in the two systems.
  5. Aesthetics: They should be pleasing to look at.[5]

In base-20 positional notation, the number twenty is written with the digit for 1 followed by the digit for 0. The Iñupiaq language does not have a word for zero, and the students decided that the Kaktovik digit 0 should look like crossed arms, meaning that nothing was being counted.[5]

When the middle-school pupils began to teach their new system to younger students in the school, the younger students tended to squeeze the numbers down to fit inside the same-sized block. In this way, they created an iconic notation with the sub-base of 5 forming the upper part of the digit, and the remainder forming the lower part. This proved visually helpful in doing arithmetic.[5]

Computation

Iñupiaq abacus designed for use with the Kaktovik numerals

Abacus

The students built base-20 abacuses in the school workshop.[4][5] These were initially intended to help the conversion from decimal to base-20 and vice versa, but the students found their design lent itself quite naturally to arithmetic in base-20. The upper section of their abacus had three beads in each column for the values of the sub-base of 5, and the lower section had four beads in each column for the remaining units.[5]

Arithmetic

An advantage the students discovered of their new system was that arithmetic was easier than with the Arabic numerals.[5] Adding two digits together would look like their sum. For example,

2 + 2 = 4
𝋂 + 𝋂 = 𝋄

It was even easier for subtraction: one could simply look at the number and remove the appropriate number of strokes to get the answer.[5] For example,

4 − 1 = 3
𝋄𝋁 = 𝋃

Another advantage came in doing long division. The visual aspects and the sub-base of five made long division with large dividends almost as easy as short division, as it didn't require writing in sub-tables for multiplying and subtracting the intermediate steps.[4] The students could keep track of the strokes of the intermediate steps with colored pencils in an elaborated system of chunking.[5]

A simplified multiplication table can be made by first finding the products of each base digit, then the products of the bases and the sub-bases, and finally the product of each sub-base:

These tables are functionally complete for multiplication operations using Kaktovik numerals, but for factors with both bases and sub-bases it is necessary to first disassociate them:

6 * 3 = 18
𝋆 * 𝋃 = (𝋁 * 𝋃) + (𝋅 * 𝋃) = 𝋒

In the above example the factor 𝋆 (6) is not found in the table, but its components, 𝋁 (1) and 𝋅 (5), are.

Legacy

The Kaktovik numerals have gained wide use among Alaskan Iñupiat. They have been introduced into language-immersion programs and have helped revive base-20 counting, which had been falling into disuse among the Iñupiat due to the prevalence of the base-10 system in English-medium schools.[4][5]

When the Kaktovik middle school students who invented the system were graduated to the high school in Barrow, Alaska (now renamed Utqiaġvik), in 1995, they took their invention with them. They were permitted to teach it to students at the local middle school, and the local community Iḷisaġvik College added an Inuit mathematics course to its catalog.[5]

In 1996, the Commission on Inuit History Language and Culture officially adopted the numerals,[5] and in 1998 the Inuit Circumpolar Council in Canada recommended the development and use of the Kaktovik numerals in that country.[6]

Significance

Scores on the California Achievement Test in mathematics for the Kaktovik middle school improved dramatically in 1997 compared to previous years. Before the introduction of the new numerals, the average score had been in the 20th percentile; after their introduction, scores rose to above the national average. It is theorized that being able to work in both base-10 and base-20 might have comparable advantages to those bilingual students have from engaging in two ways of thinking about the world.[5]

The development of an indigenous numeral system helps to demonstrate to Alaskan-native students that math is embedded in their culture and language rather than being imparted by western culture. This is a shift from a previously commonly held view that mathematics was merely a necessity to get into a college or university. Non-native students can see a practical example of a different world view, a part of ethnomathematics.[7]

In Unicode

The Kaktovik numerals were added to the Unicode Standard in September, 2022, with the release of version 15.0. Several fonts support this block.

Kaktovik Numerals[1][2]
Official Unicode Consortium code chart (PDF)
  0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 A B C D E F
U+1D2Cx 𝋀 𝋁 𝋂 𝋃 𝋄 𝋅 𝋆 𝋇 𝋈 𝋉 𝋊 𝋋 𝋌 𝋍 𝋎 𝋏
U+1D2Dx 𝋐 𝋑 𝋒 𝋓
Notes
1.^ As of Unicode version 16.0
2.^ Grey areas indicate non-assigned code points
Graphical display of Kaktovik Numerals
Official Unicode Consortium code chart (PDF)
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 A B C D E F
U+1D2Cx 𝋀 𝋁 𝋂 𝋃 𝋄 𝋅 𝋆 𝋇 𝋈 𝋉 𝋊 𝋋 𝋌 𝋍 𝋎 𝋏
U+1D2Dx 𝋐 𝋑 𝋒 𝋓

See also

  • Maya numerals, a quinary-vigesimal system from another American culture

References

  • Bartley, Wm. Clark (January–February 1997). "Making the Old Way Count" (PDF). Sharing Our Pathways. 2 (1): 12–13. Archived (PDF) from the original on June 25, 2013. Retrieved February 27, 2017.
  • Resolution 89-09: Regarding Kaktovik Numerals. Inuit Circumpolar Conference. Nuuk, Greenland. July 1998. Archived from the original on February 2, 2017.
  • Bartley, William Clark (2002). "Counting on tradition: Iñupiaq numbers in the school setting". In Hankes, Judith Elaine; Fast, Gerald R. (eds.). Perspectives on Indigenous People of North America. Changing the Faces of Mathematics. Reston, Virginia: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. pp. 225–236. ISBN 978-0873535069. Retrieved April 17, 2024.
  • Engblom-Bradley, Claudette (2009). "Seeing mathematics with Indian eyes". In Williams, Maria Sháa Tláa (ed.). The Alaska Native Reader: History, Culture, Politics. Duke University Press. pp. 237–245. doi:10.1215/9780822390831-025. ISBN 978-0-8223-4465-0.
  • MacLean, Edna Ahgeak (2012). Iñupiatun Uqaluit Taniktun Sivunniuġutiŋit [North Slope Iñupiaq to English Dictionary] (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on December 10, 2021.
  • MacLean, Edna Ahgeak (2014). Iñupiatun Uqaluit Taniktun Sivuninit [Iñupiaq to English Dictionary]. University of Alaska Press. JSTOR jj.1176788.

Further reading

Read other articles:

Katedral BeijingGereja Katedral Perawan Maria Dikandung Tanpa Noda di BeijingGereja XuanwumenHanzi: 圣母无染原罪堂Katedral BeijingLokasiBeijingNegaraTiongkokDenominasiGereja Katolik RomaArsitekturStatusKatedralStatus fungsionalAktifGayaBaroquePeletakan batu pertama1605AdministrasiKeuskupan AgungKeuskupan Agung BeijingKlerusUskup AgungYang Mulia Mgr. Joseph Li Shan Interior Katedral Nantang Katedral Nantang dari Jalan Katedral Beijing atau yang bernama resmi Katedral Perawan Maria D...

 

 

منتخب إستونيا لكرة القدم للسيدات معلومات عامة بلد الرياضة  إستونيا الفئة كرة القدم للسيدات  رمز الفيفا EST  الاتحاد اتحاد إستونيا لكرة القدم كونفدرالية يويفا (أوروبا) الملعب الرئيسي أ. لي كوك أرينا الموقع الرسمي الموقع الرسمي  الطاقم واللاعبون المدرب كيث بواناس ا...

 

 

Concert venue in Toronto, Ontario, Canada Horseshoe TavernThe Horseshoe or The 'Shoe'The Horseshoe TavernFormer namesCountry Roots n' Rockabilly Music TavernLocationToronto, Ontario, CanadaCoordinates43°38′57″N 79°23′45″W / 43.649081°N 79.395889°W / 43.649081; -79.395889OwnerCollective Concerts (Jeff Cohen)TypeNightclubGenre(s)IndieOpened1947Websitehorseshoetavern.com The Horseshoe Tavern (known as The Horseshoe, The 'Shoe', The 'Toronto Tavern' and The 'Tr...

Lithuanian newspaper in Chicago, Illinois DraugasDraugas building in Chicago, IllinoisTypecurrently thrice-weekly newspaperFormatTabloidPublisherLithuanian Catholic Press SocietyEditor-in-chiefRamunė LapasFounded1909LanguageLithuanianHeadquarters4545 W. 63rd StreetChicago, IL 60629United StatesSister newspapersDraugas NewsWebsitedraugas.org Draugas (English: Friend) is a Lithuanian-language newspaper based in Chicago. It is the only Lithuanian daily newspaper published outside of Lithuania. ...

 

 

American baseball player Baseball player Wes LittletonLittleton with the Texas Rangers in 2008Relief pitcherBorn: (1982-09-02) September 2, 1982 (age 41)Hayward, California, U.S.Batted: RightThrew: RightMLB debutJuly 4, 2006, for the Texas RangersLast MLB appearanceSeptember 26, 2008, for the Texas RangersMLB statisticsWin–loss record5–3Earned run average3.69Strikeouts55 Teams Texas Rangers (2006–2008) Wes Avi Littleton (born September 2, 1982) is an A...

 

 

1999 film by Erik Fleming This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: My Brother the Pig – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) My Brother the PigDVD coverDirected byErik FlemingWritten byMatthew FlynnProduced byDon ReardonStarring Sc...

بنك الدولة الهنديالشعارمعلومات عامةالبلد الهند[1] التأسيس 2 يونيو 1806 النوع  القائمة ... عمل تجاري — مقاولة — مؤسسة الائتمان — بنك — مؤسسة مالية[2] — شركة عمومية محدودة الشكل القانوني شركة مساهمة — شركة قانونية المقر الرئيسي مومباي الهند موقع الويب sbi.co.in (الإنج...

 

 

Municipality in Utrecht, Netherlands Municipality in Utrecht, NetherlandsWijk bij DuurstedeMunicipalityAerial view of Wijk bij Duurstede FlagCoat of armsLocation in UtrechtWijk bij DuurstedeLocation of Wijk bij DuurstedeCoordinates: 51°59′N 5°20′E / 51.983°N 5.333°E / 51.983; 5.333CountryNetherlandsProvinceUtrechtGovernment[1] • BodyMunicipal councilArea[2] • Total50.40 km2 (19.46 sq mi) • Land4...

 

 

Sinabawang gulayNama lainSup sayur Filipina, utan bisaya, sabaw na utan, law-oy, laswa, bulanglang na gulayJenisSupTempat asalFilipinaSuhu penyajianPanasBahan utamaBerbagai sayuran daunSunting kotak info • L • BBantuan penggunaan templat ini Sinabawang gulay, biasanya dikenal juga sebagai sup sayur Filipina, adalah sup sayur Filipina yang dibuat menggunakan sayuran daun (biasanya daun kelor) dan berbagai sayuran lainnya dalam kuah kaldu yang dibumbui dengan kaldu makanan laut at...

Canadian ice hockey player (born 1948) Ice hockey player Pierre Bouchard Born (1948-02-20) February 20, 1948 (age 76)Longueuil, Quebec, CanadaHeight 6 ft 2 in (188 cm)Weight 205 lb (93 kg; 14 st 9 lb)Position DefenceShot LeftPlayed for Montreal CanadiensWashington CapitalsNHL draft 5th overall, 1965Montreal CanadiensPlaying career 1970–1982 Pierre Émile Bouchard (born February 20, 1948) is a Canadian former professional ice hockey player who play...

 

 

Govind Narain Gubernur Karnataka 8Masa jabatan2 Agustus 1977 – 15 April 1983PendahuluUma Shankar DikshitPenggantiA. N. Banerji Informasi pribadiLahir(1916-05-05)5 Mei 1916Mainpuri, British RajMeninggal3 April 2012(2012-04-03) (umur 95)New Delhi, IndiaSunting kotak info • L • B Govind Narain, ICS (5 Mei 1916 – 3 April 2012) adalah seorang pegawai sipil India. Ia merupakan anggota Imperial Civil Service dan menjabat sebagai Gubernur Karnataka ke...

 

 

Canadian politician (born 1950) Judy DarcyMinister of Mental Health and Addictions of British ColumbiaIn officeJuly 18, 2017 – November 26, 2020PremierJohn HorganPreceded byPosition establishedSucceeded bySheila MalcolmsonMember of the British Columbia Legislative Assemblyfor New WestminsterIn officeMay 14, 2013 – September 21, 2020Preceded byDawn BlackSucceeded byJennifer Whiteside4th National President of the Canadian Union of Public EmployeesIn office1991–2003Preced...

Sceaux 行政国 フランス地域圏 (Région) イル=ド=フランス地域圏県 (département) オー=ド=セーヌ県郡 (arrondissement) アントニー郡小郡 (canton) 小郡庁所在地INSEEコード 92071郵便番号 92330市長(任期) フィリップ・ローラン(2008年-2014年)自治体間連合 (fr) メトロポール・デュ・グラン・パリ人口動態人口 19,679人(2007年)人口密度 5466人/km2住民の呼称 Scéens地理座標 北緯48度4...

 

 

English actress and playwright (1858–1934) Madeleine Lucette RyleyMadeleine Lucette, from an 1893 publicationBornMadeline Matilda Bradley(1858-12-26)26 December 1858London, England, United Kingdom of Great Britain and IrelandDied7 February 1934(1934-02-07) (aged 75)Hampstead, London, England, United KingdomOccupation(s)Actress and playwrightSpouseJ. H. Ryley Madeleine Lucette Ryley (26 December 1858 – 7 February 1934) was an English actress and playwright known for her plays in Londo...

 

 

Николо де Кавери Карта де Кавери. около 1505 Opus Nicolay de Caveri Januensis Пергамент, рисунок. 115 × 225 см Национальная библиотека Франции, Париж  Медиафайлы на Викискладе «Карта де Кавери» или «Планисфера де Кавери» (а также карта Каверио, Канерио, Канери) — карта гену�...

Ця стаття потребує додаткових посилань на джерела для поліпшення її перевірності. Будь ласка, допоможіть удосконалити цю статтю, додавши посилання на надійні (авторитетні) джерела. Зверніться на сторінку обговорення за поясненнями та допоможіть виправити недоліки. Мат...

 

 

2020年夏季奥林匹克运动会波兰代表團波兰国旗IOC編碼POLNOC波蘭奧林匹克委員會網站olimpijski.pl(英文)(波兰文)2020年夏季奥林匹克运动会(東京)2021年7月23日至8月8日(受2019冠状病毒病疫情影响推迟,但仍保留原定名称)運動員206參賽項目24个大项旗手开幕式:帕维尔·科热尼奥夫斯基(游泳)和马娅·沃什乔夫斯卡(自行车)[1]闭幕式:卡罗利娜·纳亚(皮划艇)&#...

 

 

Ne doit pas être confondu avec Black feminism. L’afroféminisme ou afro-féminisme est un mouvement apparu pendant la période d’émancipation féministe des années 1970, à la même période que le Black feminism aux États-Unis. L’afroféminisme, porté par des afro-descendantes (d’Afrique, des Caraïbes, d'Europe et des diasporas), est un mouvement militant qui lutte à la fois contre les systèmes d’oppression sexiste, négrophobe et parfois capitaliste. Il se situe notamment...

Частина серії проФілософіяLeft to right: Plato, Kant, Nietzsche, Buddha, Confucius, AverroesПлатонКантНіцшеБуддаКонфуційАверроес Філософи Епістемологи Естетики Етики Логіки Метафізики Соціально-політичні філософи Традиції Аналітична Арістотелівська Африканська Близькосхідна іранська Буддій�...

 

 

Indigenous tribe in the US and Mexico Ethnic group Akimel O'odhamPimaO'odham portraitsTotal population19,921 ± 4,574 (2010)[1]Regions with significant populations United States ( Arizona)LanguagesO'odham, English, SpanishReligionRoman Catholicism, traditional tribal religion[2]Related ethnic groups Ak-Chin O'odham Hia C-ed O'odham Tohono O'odham The Akimel O'odham (O'odham for river people), also called the Pima, are a group of Native Americans living in an area consisting of...