He won a move to Nottingham Forest in February 1949, just as the club suffered relegation at the end of 1948–49.[2] He scored 21 goals in 62 league and cup games for Forest, helping the club win promotion into the Second Division as champions of the Third Division South in 1950–51.[2] The club missed out on a second successive promotion in 1951–52 by just two points, after which Love moved on to Welsh side Llanelli, where he was appointed player-manager.
Love joined Walsall in March 1955, as the club floundered at the foot of the Third Division South table; he scored twice in sixteen games.[2] Having successfully applied for re-election, Walsall chose Love to replace the legendary Frank Buckley in September 1955.[2] Love picked himself for 24 league games, and scored eight goals, in 1955–56, as his side finished twentieth.[2] He then retired as a player, due to injury, and then managed the "Saddlers" to a fifteenth-place finish in 1956–57.[2]
Love took up the management reins at Third Division NorthWrexham for the 1957–58 campaign. The "Red Dragons" finished twelfth, and lifted the Welsh Cup after victory over Chester City in a replay at the Racecourse Ground. His side founded the newly formed Third Division in 1958–59, and ended the season in eighteenth place. He stepped down at the end of the campaign. He returned to Edinburgh and took up a post with a furniture company and went on to become sales director.