Kinloch was for many years one of the best-known coaches for university examinations in Sydney. He established a college, but he lost money in land speculation, and he died after financial difficulties and illness, leaving a widow.[5][6]
Although he was a big man who moved slowly, Kinloch was a fast-medium under-arm bowler, renowned for his accuracy, who spun the ball from the leg. He took 4 for 14 and 4 for 56 in the match against Victoria in 1859. As he was near-sighted, he wore a monocle while playing.[7][8] He was also a noted yachtsman.[4]