Originally from St Peter's Football Club in the Moorabbin Saints Junior Football League, Fidge made his VFL debut for Melbourne as a 17-year-old centre half forward in 1984, starring with four goals and 23 disposals in a loss to Essendon. He finished his first season with 27 goals from 12 appearances, missing games mid year with a knee injury.
Fidge played 16 matches in 1985 and booted six goals against North Melbourne at the MCG, his best return for Melbourne. It was also the first year where he played alongside his brother Ted at Melbourne. He suffered from stress fractures in his foot during 1986 but kicked 12 goals from his four games.[1]
Fidge joined the new Brisbane Bears team for their inaugural season in 1987 and played in every one of their first eight games. Late in the season Fidge kicked six goals against Fitzroy to equal his career best and kicked a further five goals and six behinds the following week against his former club. Injuries returned in 1998 and Fidge, who had an icy relationship with coach Peter Knights, was sacked a few games into the 1989 VFL season.
For the rest of 1989, Fidge played with Glenelg in the SANFL. He was selected by the Sydney Swans in the 1989 VFL Draft but chose to remain in South Australia. His decision to stay at Glenelg in 1990 paid off, as he kicked 124 goals for the year, five of them in the Grand Final loss to Port Adelaide.[2] Despite his large goal tally for the season Fidge did not take home the Ken Farmer Medal, which went to Port Adelaide's Scott Hodges, who kicked 153 goals.
Recruited by Essendon with the 24th pick of the 1990 AFL Draft, Fidge did not play a senior game for them and returned to Glenelg.[3]
He again topped Glenelg's goal-kicking in 1992 with 92 goals and once more finished second in the league. Glenelg made the Grand Final once again, but Fidge's four goals were not enough to get them over the line. The following year he kicked a more modest 56 goals but it saw him top his club's goal-kicking for the third and final time.
Fidge spent the 1994 season with VFL side Frankston before retiring.