The performance earned him a call-up to the American League and the Philadelphia Athletics in August, but Taylor hit only .224 with 13 hits in 18 games during the franchise's waning days in its original home city. He did not make the move to Kansas City with the Athletics, spending 1955 with three clubs at the top levels of the minors. Two strong campaigns and an All-Star selection as a member of the Seattle Rainiers of the Open-Classification Pacific Coast League got him a late-season trial with the 1957Cincinnati Redlegs. Taylor batted .262 with 28 hits (including four home runs) in 33 games over the final two months of the season, including 24 starts as a corner outfielder. At season's end, however, he was included in a five-player December 5 trade in which the Redlegs, seeking pitching help, sent him and a young future All-Star centerfielder, Curt Flood, to the St. Louis Cardinals for three hurlers.[3]
Taylor began 1958 at Triple-A Omaha before his recall to St. Louis late in May. Playing sparingly, he batted .304 in 23 at bats, largely as a pinch hitter, before he was claimed on waivers by the Baltimore Orioles on July 25. He played in 50 games for Baltimore over two seasons, but batted a composite .239. His last major-league appearance came July 21, 1959, as a pinch hitter against his first-ever MLB team, the Athletics. He then returned to the Triple-A Vancouver Mounties, where he was selected to the Pacific Coast League All-Star team for a second time. He played in the high minors in the United States and Mexico through 1963 before retiring.
