His coaching hires included Chris Lamb as volleyball coach, Tom McCurdy as women's golf coach, Steve Rainbolt as track and field coach, Mark Turgeon and Gregg Marshall for men's basketball, Jody Adams for women's basketball, and Tim Walton for softball. All of these hires guided Wichita State to NCAA tournaments.[11]
Schaus hired Bob Boldon as the head coach of the women's basketball team in 2013. Under Boldon Ohio had one of the best stretches of success in program history. Ohio had winning seasons each of the final six years of Schaus' tenure at Ohio. They won the MAC East in 2015, 2016, and 2019. Ohio won the 2015 MAC tournament and qualified for the NCAA tournament.[26][27] In 2019 Ohio won a school record 30 games.[28]
Ohio's volleyball team won seven MAC Championships while Schaus was AD and appeared in five NCAA Regionals.[29] The baseball and softball teams each won two MAC Championships.[30] Ohio's graduation rate for athletes during his tenure was 88%.[31] Schaus inherited a $2.3 million budget deficit upon arriving at Ohio but balanced the budget during every year of his tenure.[32]
In 2015 he began a term as one of the 10 members on the selection committee for the NCAA Division I men's basketball tournament.[33] In January 2017 the NCAA began looking to replace the Rating percentage index as the rating system used as the primary team sorting tool by the selection committee.[34] Schaus and Dan Gavitt, the NCAA's senior vice president of basketball, met with Jeff Sagarin, Kevin Pauga (KPI), Ken Pomeroy, and Ben Alamar (ESPN BPI) to begin the process of considering a new alternative.[35] The eventual result was the NET Rankings.[36]
Southern Conference
On July 1, 2019, Schaus was hired as Commissioner of the Southern Conference.[37] Southern Conference Basketball has performed at its highest level in decades both in terms of the quality of top teams and conference depth.[38] Schaus implemented a new scheduling model to enhance the chances of success for Southern Conference programs.[1] In 2019 the Southern Conference finished 10th in the NET rankings.[1]Wofford finished the season ranked #19 and defeated Seton Hall in the first round of the NCAA tournament.[39]UNC Greensboro and Furman both qualified for the NIT[40]
During the COVID-19 pandemic he announced that 2020 Spring Conference sports were cancelled[41] and before the 2020-21 FCS Football Season, like most FCS conferences, the Southern Conference would play in the spring.[42] The Southern Conference was the only FCS conference to have all teams compete during that season.[43]
In February 2023, Schaus announced his retirement effective June 30. Michael Cross, a veteran college sports administrator who had most recently served with the Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics, was named as his successor.[44]