In 2015, Rothe had leading roles in the comedy film Lily & Kat, the Netflix science fiction pilot Parallels, and the crime drama film The Preppie Connection.[17][18][19] That same year, she was cast as Alexis in Damien Chazelle's musical film La La Land.[20][21] Rothe was drawn to the role since as a child, "I just thought that living in a world where any moment someone could burst into song and dance would be the dreamiest thing in the world".[20] Released in 2016, the film was a critical and commercial success.[22][23]
In 2016, Rothe had her first leading role in a television series, playing Paige in the MTV comedy series Mary + Jane.[24] Described as a "weed-comedy" and produced by Snoop Dogg, the show ran for one season.[25][26] The show earned mixed reviews,[27] though critics praised the acting of Rothe and her co-star Scout Durwood. Daniel Fienberg of The Hollywood Reporter said that they "have a rapport that feels natural and unforced, even if so much of the rest of the show feels often wildly forced, or at least like its trying too hard."[28]
2017–present: Breakthrough
In 2017, Rothe starred in the Christopher Landon horror film Happy Death Day—originally titled Half to Death—as Theresa "Tree" Gelbman.[29][30] The character was written with the intention of having more depth than the average slasher character, part of which is reflected through the nickname Tree as "trees need to grow and you see this character go from one person to another".[30][31]Happy Death Day was a significant box office success,[32][33][34] and was called a "starmaking" film for Rothe.[35] Writing for RogerEbert.com, Brian Tallerico said that Rothe was "quite good in a way that makes me eager to see what she does next. Her performance is quite easily the best thing about the movie."[36] Simran Hans of The Guardian described her as "endlessly watchable and witty".[37] Jeannette Catsoulis of The New York Times called her "unimprovable", "inexhaustable and funny".[38] The character has been called an example of the "final girl" trope, and established Rothe as a scream queen.[39][40][41][42] She was nominated for a Fright Meter Award and a New Mexico Film Critics Circle Award.[43][44]
In 2018, Rothe played Josie in the romance film Forever My Girl, which she accepted based on the themes of strength and female empowerment.[45] Her sole release of that year, the film received negative reviews from critics.
In 2019, Rothe reprised the role of Tree Gelbman in Happy Death Day 2U, a direct sequel to Happy Death Day.[46] The film was conceived by Landon before its predecessor was released,[47] and Rothe was initially hesitant feeling that a sequel could potentially retread the original. However, she was convinced by Landon's pitch and believed it "elevates the movie from being a horror movie into a Back to the Future type of genre film where the sequel joins us right from where we left off, it explains a lot of things in the first one that didn't get explained, and it elevates everything."[45] It was released to similar critical and financial success,[48][49] and Rothe earned a second Fright Meter Award nomination.[50]
In 2020, Rothe had starring roles in two films: the jukebox musical Valley Girl, a remake of the 1983 film of the same name, and the romantic drama All My Life.[51][52]Valley Girl sees Rothe play Julie, who was played by Deborah Foreman in the original film.[53] In All My Life, she plays Jennifer "Jenn" Carter. Both films garnered a mixed reception from critics, though Rothe's performances earned some praise.[54][55] Also in 2020, she appeared in four episodes of the Amazon Prime Video series Utopia.[56] Rothe said that "working with Gillian Flynn and the incredible cast in Chicago was a dream job, and I’m so excited for audiences to go through that emotional rollercoaster. It’s unique, fun and tragic all at the same time."[57]
Rothe next starred in the crime drama film Body Brokers.[58][59] She was cast in 2019, and the film was released in 2021,[60] her sole release of that year. Though he gave the film a mixed review, Peter Sobczynski of RoberEbert.com said Rothe and co-star Melissa Leo "do strong work as those who represent the non-exploitative side of the rehabilitation world."[61]
In 2022, Rothe replaced actress Samara Weaving in the action film Boy Kills World;[62] the film premiered at the 2023 Toronto International Film Festival, and was theatrically released in April 2024.[63][64] Lauren Coates of The A.V. Club said that Rothe's character was "underwritten and enters the game too late to be effectively used. Her helmet gimmick is mistakenly substituted for a personality—a truly grievous waste of a charming young talent."[65] More positively, Chase Hutchinson of The Seattle Times said her performance "provided redemption."[66] She reprises the role in a spin-off game, Super Dragon Punch Force 3, released that same month.[67]
Upcoming projects
Rothe will next star in the survival thriller film Titan, alongside Kiana Madeira.[68]
Personal life
On February 14, 2019, Rothe announced that she was engaged to actor Eric Clem.[69] They married on September 12, 2020, in Morrison, Colorado.[70]