"Murder at the 18th St. Garage" Released: September 26, 2023
Jenny from Thebes is the 22nd studio album by indie folk band the Mountain Goats, released on October 27, 2023, through Merge Records. The album serves as a sequel to the band's 2002 release All Hail West Texas,[2] and is structured as a rock opera[1] which tells the story of the character "Jenny" (from the band's previous albums, including All Hail West Texas, along with 2001's Jam Eater Blues and 2012's Transcendental Youth). Lyricist John Darnielle describes the album as being about "the individual and society", and about Jenny's "southwestern ranch style house, the people for whom that house is a place of safety, and the west Texas town that is uncomfortable with its existence."[3]
Jenny from Thebes received a score of 80 out of 100 on review aggregator Metacritic based on seven critics' reviews, indicating "generally favorable" reviews.[5]Uncut stated that "familiarity with the back-story is not necessary to enjoy this potted indie-rock opera: as always with Darnielle's work, an appreciation of droll storytelling and deadpan melodies will do".[8] Reviewing the album for Exclaim!, Eric Hill felt that it "manages to truly distill the manic energy of the Mountain Goats' formative phase into a maturing yet vital shape, giving it a place in the upper reaches of their pantheon".[6]Paste named it album of the week, with the reviewer Laura Dzubay writing that "while Jenny from Thebes feels big compared to the Mountain Goats' stripped-down albums, there's restraint on these songs, and the rock-opera approach never feels garish", calling it "a fitting new record" from the band.[7] John Amen of No Depression wrote, "Jenny From Thebes spotlights The Mountain Goats as they explore various sonic balances, Darnielle exercising his narrative and impressionistic bents." He concluded by describing the album as "a largely engaging, if occasionally 'lite,' set."[9]