Biased: Uncovering the Hidden Prejudice That Shapes What We See, Think, and Do
Jennifer Lynn Eberhardt (born January 1, 1965) is an American social psychologist who is currently a professor in the Department of Psychology at Stanford University.[1] Eberhardt has been responsible for major contributions on investigating the consequences of the psychological association between race and crime through methods such as field studies and laboratory studies.[2] She has also contributed to research on unconscious bias, including demonstrating how racial imagery and judgment affect culture and society within the domain of social justice.[1] The results from her work have contributed to training law enforcement officers and state agencies to better their judgments through implicit bias training.[3] She has also provided directions for future research in this domain and brought attention to mistreatment in communities due to biases.
Eberhardt was born in Cleveland, Ohio, and is the youngest of five children. She was raised in Lee–Harvard, a predominantly African-American middle-class neighborhood. When she was twelve, her family relocated to Beachwood, Ohio, where she graduated from Beachwood High School.[9][10]
Eberhardt credits her interest in race and inequality on her family's move from the predominantly African-American working-class neighbourhood of Lee-Harvard to the white suburb of Beachwood. The two neighbourhoods differed in terms of resources and opportunities despite their close proximity.[4] She noticed that she and her non African-American classmates experienced life differently, such as her father and brothers being pulled over more frequently than other residents.[11] This further increased her interest in racial inequality and changed her approach to understanding the world.[9]
From July 1993 to July 1994, Eberhardt was a postdoctoral research associate in the Social and Personality Psychology Division at the University of Massachusetts. Here, she conducted research on stereotyping and inter-group relations. She was a postdoctoral research associate in the Department of Psychology at Stanford University, from September 1994 to June 1995, where she researched the impact of stereotype threat on academic performance. From July 1995 to June 1998, Eberhardt worked as an assistant professor at Yale University in the Department of Psychology and the Department of African Studies and African-American Studies. In September 1998, she accepted a teaching position at Stanford University in the Department of Psychology as an assistant professor. In May 2005, she was appointed as an associate professor, and at some point she became a full professor.[9][1] Eberhardt is also the co-director and faculty co-founder of Stanford's SPARQ (Social Psychological Answers to Real-World Questions) program. This center at Stanford brings together many industry leaders, researchers and well known faces in society to inspire cultural changes using insights from the behavioral sciences. Through SPARQ, Eberhardt demonstrates the consequences of racial associations in criminal justice, education and business.[1]
Research
Implicit bias
Eberhardt and her colleagues developed research that introduced alternative approaches to considering race and ethnicity.[13] In 2008, she published a study that sought to examine how the variations in beliefs regarding the root of racial differences can impact social interactions.[13] The study's findings revealed that those who believed racial differences arise due to biological differences differed from those who looked at race as a social construct.[13] Those who view racial differences as biologically influenced are, according to this study, less likely to express interest in interracial relationships.[14] These people were also at a higher risk of promoting race-based stereotypes, were less likely to set aside inequalities and defended these inequalities as a product of innate racial differences.[13] When people perceive racial differences as biologically determined, they create strict barriers between themselves and racial out-groups.[14] This impacts the well-being of members of historically disadvantaged racial groups.[14]
Golby and Eberhardt's research focused on why humans are more likely to recognize people in their own race over those in another race.[15] African-American and European-American subjects looked at images of unfamiliar African-American and European-American faces while getting fMRI scans.[15][16] There was 1.5 times more activation in the right hemisphere of the brain, specifically the fusiform face areas (FFAs), when looking at same-race faces.[15][16] Another finding was that memory recognition was greater for recognizing same-race faces in European-Americans which showed higher activation in the left fusiform cortex and the right hippocampal and parahippocampal regions.[15] This demonstrates that own- and other-race faces stimulate differential activation in the FFAs, however it does not explain why activation for same-race faces takes place in right side of the brain and memory encoding takes place in the left side of the brain. This can be an area for future research.[15][17]
Criminal justice
Eberhardt's research demonstrated how the automatic effect of implicit racial stereotypes impacts one's visual processing.[18] A series of studies focusing on priming were conducted, specifically priming individuals with images related to crime.[19] The intention was to see whether individuals would focus on White or Black faces when cued for crime. The study showed that people and officers specifically focused more on Black faces. The next study focused solely on officers who were separated into two groups, those who were primed for crime and those who weren't. They were presented with a picture of a Black or White suspect and were asked to complete a memory task where they had to identify the suspect in a lineup with other suspects of the same race. Some lineups had suspects with highly stereotypical features of each respective race, whereas others had less stereotypical facial features. Crime-primed officers who viewed a Black suspect misremembered the suspect with someone who had more stereotypical Black features; but crime primed officers who saw a White suspect were less likely to identify a less stereotypical White suspect and more likely to associate it with a more stereotypical Black face.[19] Eberhardt's research shows how racial associations can impact the public's perception of Black people and crime and how this can influence how White people would misremember or neglect evidence that isn't accurate for a Black defendant.[20] This also introduces future directions for research such as the cognitive accessibility of primed information.[20]
In a 2006 study, Eberhardt and her colleagues examined databases in Philadelphia which examined whether the likelihood of being sentenced to death is related to the defendant looking stereotypically Black (thick lips, dark skin, dark hair, broad noses) when the victim was either Black or White. Those who were stereotypically Black were sentenced to death 57.5 percent of the time compared to 24.4 percent of the lighter African-Americans, especially if the victims were White. This research provides evidence that physical traits alone can influence sentencing decisions to quite an extent.[21]
In a related 2008 study, Eberhardt and her colleagues conducted an analysis on printed newspaper articles regarding Caucasian and African-American convicts in line for the death penalty.[22] This study was rooted in the notion that African-American males are frequently wrongly accused, misjudged and wrongfully remembered as aggressors.[23] During the analysis of the newspaper articles, the researchers' main focus was on detecting "ape imagery" (this included characterizing a person as a beast, hairy, wild).[22] They found this imagery was significantly more common for African-Americans than Caucasians.[22] In the case of African-Americans, the ape imagery also predicted who would be sentenced to the death penalty.[22] The research done by Eberhardt demonstrated not only the mistreatment of African-American detainees, but also the lack of civil rights available to members of other lower-status groups who are often misjudged as aggressors.[24]
In 2012, Eberhardt and colleagues studied how racial stereotypes can affect a juror's perception of the legal distinction between a juvenile and adult criminal offender. Participants read non-homicide case studies depicting either a Black or White juvenile offender. They found White Americans were more likely to support severe sentences when they read case studies depicting a Black juvenile offender than when the offender's race was changed to White.[25] This was because white offenders' behaviour was more likely to be attributed to youthful indiscretion while Black offenders were more likely to be perceived as having the maturity and criminal intentions of adults.[26][27]
In another study in 2014, Eberhardt and Hetey (a Stanford University colleague) examined how just the mere exposure of racial disparities can impact an individual's support for harsh criminal justice policies. White participants were split into two groups, in group one they watched a video clip in which 25 percent of the images were of Black inmates and in group two, 45 percent of the images were of Black inmates. They were then informed of strict criminal laws abiding in the state of California, followed by a petition form to sign to amend the laws and make them less harsh. From group one, more than 50 percent of the participants signed the petition, whereas only 28 percent of group two agreed to sign it.[28]
In 2015, the Oakland Police Department committed to participate in President Barack Obama's Police Data Initiative.[29] Through SPARQ, Eberhardt worked with the Oakland Police Department to analyze police stop data for racial disparities. They used computational linguistics to assess interactions between officers and members of the Oakland community. Although they found no explicit bias, they found that when speaking to white drivers, officers were reassuring, used positive words, and expressed concern for safety. In contrast, when officers were speaking to Black drivers, they more often used negative terms, stuttered,[30] used informal language, and used less explanatory terms.[19] The researchers made fifty recommendations for critical changes within the Oakland Police Department, many of which have been implemented as of the report's 2017 release. The recommendations create a model that spans four categories: data analysis, policies and practices, training, and community engagement. As of 2017, Eberhardt and her team have since given bias training to ninety percent of the Oakland Police Department's officers.[3]
Bias in the education system
Okonofua and Eberhardt (2015) examined teachers' responses to students' misbehaviors, and whether there were racial differences in how these responses were directed. The study discovered teachers' responses contributed to racial disparities in discipline in the sense that Black students are more likely to be labeled as "troublemakers" than White students.[31] It was also found that when students of color and White students commit similar behaviors, the behaviors are viewed as being more serious for students of color.[32] Black students' misbehaviors are more likely to be viewed as a pattern than White students. The study also found that responses given by teachers may potentially drive racial differences in students' behaviors.[33]
In 2016, Okonofua, Walton, and Eberhardt ran a meta-analysis on past research literature examining how social-psychological factors play a role in the structure of racial disparities in teacher-student relationships. Findings in the research suggest pervasive negative stereotypes may give rise to mistrustful relationships between racially stigmatized students and teachers. For example, in instances where Black students are often given the label of 'troublemakers', students may feel stigmatized and have distrust for teachers, thus they are more likely to misbehave in the future.[34] As a result, such teachers' interactions with students through frequent labelling can potentially produce a never-ending cycle of increased punishment and misbehaviors.[34] Due to such issue, a discipline gap is produced, which results in Black students having less opportunity to learn.[35] The meta-analysis also noted an approach that has been implemented in over 7000 schools in the U.S. called the Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports approach (PBIS), the authors argued although the approach aims to improve students' behavior, the subject of positive teacher-student relationship is neglected. Therefore, future interventions should aim to solve psychological barriers in order to reinforce positive teacher-student relationships rather than placing the majority of emphasis on teaching social skills, or prescriptive rules.[36]
^ abcdMarkus, Hazel Rose (2008). "Pride, prejudice, and ambivalence: toward a unified theory of race and ethnicity". American Psychologist. 63 (8): 651–670. doi:10.1037/0003-066X.63.8.651. PMID19014214.
^ abcSanchez, Diana T; Garcia, Julie A (2009). "When Race Matters: Racially Stigmatized Others and Perceiving Race as a Biological Construction Affect Biracial People's Daily Well-Being". Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 35 (9): 1154–1164. doi:10.1177/0146167209337628. PMID19644133. S2CID17258546.
^Smith, Jessi L; Johnson, Camille S (2006). "A stereotype boost or choking under pressure? positive gender stereotypes and men who are low in domain identification". Basic and Applied Social Psychology. 28 (1): 51–63. doi:10.1207/s15324834basp2801_5. S2CID145684776.
^ abcWeisburd, David; Majmundar, Malay K (2018). Proactive Policing: Effects on Crime and Communities. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press: National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. p. 280. ISBN978-0-309-46713-1.
^ abCollerton, Daniel; Perry, Elaine; McKeith, Ian (2005). "Why people see things that are not there: A novel Perception and Attention Deficit model for recurrent complex visual hallucinations". Behavioral and Brain Sciences. 28 (6): 737–757. doi:10.1017/S0140525X05000130. PMID16372931. S2CID31813489.
^ abcdLeyens, Jacques-Philippe; Demoulin, Stephanie; Vaes, Jeroen; Guant, Ruth; Paladino, Maria Paola (2007). "Infra-humanization: The Wall of Group Differences". Social Issues and Policy Review. 1 (1): 139–172. doi:10.1111/j.1751-2409.2007.00006.x.
^Conrad, Courtenay R; Croco, Sarah E; Gomez, Brad T; Moore, Whill H (2018). "Threat perception and American support for torture". Political Behavior. 40 (4): 989–1009. doi:10.1007/s11109-017-9433-5. S2CID149107960.
^Collins, Catherine Fisher, ed. (2015). Black girls and adolescents: facing the challenges. Santa Barbara, California. ISBN9781440830532. OCLC881440013.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
^Blume, Arthur W., ed. (2017). Social issues in living color: challenges and solutions from the perspective of ethnic minority psychology. Santa Barbara, California. ISBN9781440833366. OCLC953984780.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
^Bornstein, Brian H.; Greene, Edie (2017). The jury under fire: myth, controversy, and reform. New York, NY. ISBN9780190201340. OCLC957554794.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
Koordinat: 43°38′48″N 79°23′25″W / 43.64667°N 79.39028°W / 43.64667; -79.39028 Minikino Film WeekMFW Popup Cinema - Bali International Short Film FestivalLokasiBali, IndonesiaDidirikan2015Tanggal festival15 - 23 September 2023BahasaInternasional[www.minikino.org/filmweek/ Situs web resmi] Minikino Film Week Bali International Short Film Festival atau MFW adalah sebuah festival film pendek internasional di Bali - Indonesia yang diselenggarakan sejak 2015 dan...
Artikel ini tidak memiliki referensi atau sumber tepercaya sehingga isinya tidak bisa dipastikan. Tolong bantu perbaiki artikel ini dengan menambahkan referensi yang layak. Tulisan tanpa sumber dapat dipertanyakan dan dihapus sewaktu-waktu.Cari sumber: Gerakan Non-Blok – berita · surat kabar · buku · cendekiawan · JSTOR Gerakan Non-Blok (GNB)Non-Aligned MovementNegara-negara anggota Gerakan Non-Blok (2005). Warna biru muda merupakan negara peninjau.Bir...
Keuskupan Agung LouisvilleArchidioecesis LudovicopolitanaKatolik LokasiNegaraAmerika SerikatWilayahKentucky TengahProvinsi gerejawiKeuskupan Agung LouisvillePopulasi- Katolik218,000 (17.7%)InformasiDenominasiKatolik RomaRitusRitus RomaPendirian8 April 1808KatedralKatedral Maria Diangkat Ke SurgaPelindungSanto YosefKepemimpinan kiniPausFransiskusUskup AgungJoseph Edward KurtzPetaSitus webwww.archlou.org Katedral Maria Diangkat Ke Surga di Louisville Keuskupan Agung Louisville te...
Marie KondoKondo pada 2016Nama asal近藤 麻理恵LahirTemplat:9 Oktober 1984TokyoTempat tinggalLos Angeles, California, ASKebangsaanJepangAlmamaterUniversitas Kristen Putri TokyoPekerjaanKonsultan tata ruangpenulisTahun aktif1997–sekarangDikenal atasBuku-buku tata ruang dan metode KonMariKarya terkenalThe Life-Changing Magic of Tidying UpSuami/istriTakumi Kawahara (m. 2012)Anak2Situs webkonmari.com Marie Kondo (近藤 麻理恵code: ja is deprecat...
Pilot episode of Friends 1st episode of the 1st season of Friends The PilotFriends episodeEpisode no.Season 1Episode 1Directed byJames BurrowsWritten byDavid Crane &Marta KauffmanFeatured music Sky Blue and Black by Jackson Browne Time of the Season by The Zombies The Star-Spangled Banner by John Stafford Smith Original air dateSeptember 22, 1994 (1994-09-22)Guest appearances John Allen Nelson as Paul the Wine Guy Clea Lewis as Franny Episode chronology ← Previo...
Italian football club Football clubMonterosiFull nameMonterosi Tuscia Football Club S.r.l.[1]Founded1968; 56 years ago (1968)[2][3][4]GroundStadio Enrico Rocchi,Viterbo, ItalyCapacity5,460ChairmanMauro FusanoManagerRoberto TaurinoLeagueSerie C Group C2022–23Serie C Group C, 16th of 20 Home colours Away colours Monterosi Tuscia Football Club, commonly known just as Monterosi, is an Italian association football club located in Monterosi, Lazio...
College basketball team UTSA Roadrunners 2023–24 UTSA Roadrunners men's basketball team UniversityUniversity of Texas at San AntonioFirst season1981All-time record444–411 (.519)Head coachAustin Claunch (1st season)ConferenceThe AmericanLocationSan Antonio, TexasArenaConvocation Center (Capacity: 2,650)NicknameRoadrunnersColorsNavy blue, orange, and white[1] Uniforms Home Away NCAA tournament appearances1988, 1999, 2004, 2011Conference to...
Preparation of soil by mechanical agitation Tillage after corn harvest (Click for video) Tillage is the agricultural preparation of soil by mechanical agitation of various types, such as digging, stirring, and overturning. Examples of human-powered tilling methods using hand tools include shoveling, picking, mattock work, hoeing, and raking. Examples of draft-animal-powered or mechanized work include ploughing (overturning with moldboards or chiseling with chisel shanks), rototilling, rolling...
Automotive classified website focused on the United States Cars.comType of siteOnline motoringAvailable inEnglishOwnerCars.com Inc.URLwww.cars.comCommercialYesLaunchedJune 1998; 25 years ago (1998-06)Current statusActiveContent licenseYes Cars.com Inc.Company typePublic companyTraded asNYSE: CARSS&P 600 componentIndustryAutomotive marketing servicesFoundedMay 2017; 7 years ago (2017-05)FoundersMitch GolubWilliam SwislowAlex Vett...
يفتقر محتوى هذه المقالة إلى الاستشهاد بمصادر. فضلاً، ساهم في تطوير هذه المقالة من خلال إضافة مصادر موثوق بها. أي معلومات غير موثقة يمكن التشكيك بها وإزالتها. (يناير 2016) هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. ...
Fotograma de Warren Beatty y Faye Dunaway, protagonistas en la película Bonnie and Clyde, 1967. Nuevo Hollywood o Renacimiento de Hollywood (New Hollywood o Hollywood Renaissance en inglés) fue un período cinematográfico estadounidense. Comenzó desde 1966, con el estreno de La jauría humana, y siguió hasta principios de los años 1980, modernizando significativamente la producción de películas en Hollywood. Este cine, inscrito en la contracultura e influenciado por el neorrealismo it...
Diverse languages between the Black and Caspian seas This article includes a list of general references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding inline citations. Please help to improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (June 2011) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Ethnolinguistic groups in the Caucasus region (1995) The Caucasian languages comprise a large and extremely varied array of languages spoken by more than ten million people in and around the Caucasus Mount...
Samsung KnoxTipeperangkat lunak dan security framework (en) Versi pertamaMaret 2013 (2013-03)EponimFort Knox Karakteristik teknisSistem operasiAndroid and TizenInformasi pengembangPengembangSamsung GroupInformasi tambahanSitus webwww.samsungknox.com/en Sunting di Wikidata • Sunting kotak info • L • BBantuan penggunaan templat ini Samsung Knox adalah kerangka kerja keamanan dan manajemen eksklusif yang telah diinstal sebelumnya pada sebagian besar perangkat seluler S...
جون فان لوتام معلومات شخصية الميلاد 10 أبريل 1976 (العمر 48 سنة)أنتاناناريفو الطول 1.85 م (6 قدم 1 بوصة) الجنسية هولندا الوزن 72 كيلوغرام استعمال اليد اليد اليمنى الحياة العملية بداية الاحتراف 1994 التقاعد 2007 مجموع الجوائز المادية 1188163 دولار فردي السجل(ف-خ): 62–99 أعلى تص�...
Chain of volcanoes formed above a subducting plate Not to be confused with Volcanic belt. Volcanic arc formation along a subducting plate A volcanic arc (also known as a magmatic arc[1]: 6.2 ) is a belt of volcanoes formed above a subducting oceanic tectonic plate,[2] with the belt arranged in an arc shape as seen from above. Volcanic arcs typically parallel an oceanic trench, with the arc located further from the subducting plate than the trench. The oceanic p...
This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Tropical cyclones in 2023 – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (January 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Tropical cyclones in 2023Year summary mapYear boundariesFirst system03FFormedJanuary 5, 2023Last systemAlvaroDissipatedJanuary 3,...
Canadian curler (born 1980) Kevin FolkCurlerBorn (1980-07-26) July 26, 1980 (age 44)Saskatoon, SaskatchewanCurling career Brier appearances3 (2008, 2011, 2012)Top CTRS ranking10th (2007–08, 2009–10)Grand Slam victories0 Medal record Curling World Junior Championships 2000 Geising Kevin Folk (born July 26, 1980 in Saskatoon, Saskatchewan) is a Canadian curler from Kelowna, British Columbia. He previously played third for Jim Cotter. Career Folk won the 2000 Canadian Junior Curling Cha...