Rockwell used Van Brunt as a model so often that the Post editors started complaining.[5]
Van Brunt's covers
The following is a list of The Saturday Evening Post covers for which Van Brunt modeled:[5]
The Hobo, October 18, 1924
Crossword Puzzles, January 31, 1925
The Old Sign Painter, February 6, 1926
The first cover after Van Brunt had shaved off his mustache, for which Rockwell paid him $10 to do in order to continue using him as a model[5]
The Phrenologist, March 27, 1926
The Bookworm, August 14, 1926
Dreams of Long Ago, August 13, 1927
Van Brunt was a widower, but still apparently mourned for Annabelle, his late wife. Rockwell's painting, Dreams of Long Ago, was a result of Rockwell inadvertently barging in on Van Brunt remembering his trip with Annabelle to the 1893 Columbian Exposition in Chicago.
Gilding the Eagle, May 26, 1928
The Wedding March, June 23, 1928
This is the next-to-last cover in which Van Brunt appears. According to the book Norman Rockwell and The Saturday Evening Post: The Early Years, he appeared in one more cover, that of January 12, 1929, as three gossiping old ladies.