Pierce tried again in the 1985 election. During the election campaign he criticized local Indians for expecting more "giveaways and handouts". He said he would not campaign on reserves as he received less than 10% of the votes from those constituencies. Some Conservative supporters were less sanguine about Pierce's candidacy as they believed his beliefs were too far to the right.[4] Despite this, Pierce defeated New Democratic Party candidate Howard Hampton by 278 votes.[5] The Progressive Conservatives won a tenuous minority government in this election, but were defeated in the legislature in June 1985 by a motion of non-confidence.
In November 1985, he supported Larry Grossman for party leader after Miller stepped down.[6] Pierce served for the next two years as a member of the opposition. He finished third in the 1987 election, losing to Howard Hampton by 2,051 votes.[7]