In Trenton, New Jersey, old high school buddies Wally (now an executive in public relations) and Alvin (a furniture mover) discuss the possibility of adding some spice to their lives by having a foursome. Alvin suggests to his wife Cleo that they share their bed with Monica, Wally's wife. Cleo thinks that she would enjoy Wally. They agree that whoever enters first becomes the evening's partner, but the couple walks in together. After Monica leaves, the three discuss the situation and decide on a foursome on Christmas Eve.
Alvin and Cleo arrive for dinner on Christmas Eve, and while Monica is initially unhappy with the arrangement, she ultimately agrees. Too excited to eat: they undress, get into bed, and have some pot to relax. As Wally suggests ideas from a sex manual, the group discards all the options.
Song list
Act I
We're Still Friends - Company
Monica - Alvin, Monica and Four Guys
By Threes - Wally, Alvin and Harvey
A Mover's Life - Alvin and Four Guys
Love Revolution - Cleo
Someone Wonderful I Missed - Monica and Cleo
Sexually Free - Alvin, Cleo and Wally
Act II
Hey There, Good Times - Harvey, Stanley, Quentin and Norman
Lovers on Christmas Eve - Monica, Wally and Norman
Scream - Harvey, Stanley, Quentin and Norman
Everybody Today is Turning On - Alvin and Wally
Married Couple Seeks Married Couple - Alvin, Cleo, Wally and Monica
The band consisted of four on-stage musicians who were among the friends and acted in the opening scene. The show was filled with their shenanigans in the background during the songs. They sang along with some of the numbers and sometimes one of them took a solo and sang alone.
The Helen Hayes Theatre in Nyack, New York, presented the musical in April 2004.[6]
Clive Barnes, reviewing for The New York Times, wrote that the musical is "bright, inventive, amusing and breezy." He noted that what Coleman and Stewart did regarding the band "is breathtakingly simple, but none...has ever done it before. They have taken the band and put it up on stage...The musicians are welded into the play, as a kind of Greek chorus." He especially noted that "It is a gorgeous cast-just right." Finally, he called the musical "mildly sexy, vastly diverting and highly amusing."[8]