The recording is based on an energetic band performance that gives prominence to a heavy drum sound. The lyrics focus on sexual frustration in a deteriorating relationship. The single reached No. 9 on both Billboard and Cash Box and top 30 in Sweden, Italy, and Canada. On the album's release, it was praised by critics for the band's musicianship and Springsteen's vocals and lyrics. Later it received favorable rankings in retrospectives of Springsteen's career, among which was an NME list calling it his fourth best song.
He at first recorded a number of full-band versions of Nebraska songs, including "Atlantic City", "Nebraska", and "Mansion on the Hill".[7] However, he and his co-producers were dissatisfied with the recordings.[7] To buy time to decide on the best approach for these songs, by May 1982 the band had begun to record other material he had written.[7] "I'm Goin' Down" was recorded over May 12–13,[6][8] with Toby Scott as the audio engineer, and Billy Straus one of his assistants.[6] In 2012, Clinton Heylin wrote that throughout the ten recorded takes of the song, Springsteen let the band "vamp away, only to curtail them in the final mix".[8] Eventually, Springsteen released ten of the solo recordings from the January cassette as the Nebraska album,[9] which came out in September 1982,[10] and temporarily shelved "I'm Goin' Down" and other band tracks from May.[11][n 1]
In 1983, he recorded more songs with the E Street Band, but was considering using solo tracks for his next album, which eventually became Born in the U.S.A., as he had done for Nebraska.[15] By the following year, Landau and Plotkin had convinced Springsteen to release band tracks, including several from May 1982 and a number of subsequently recorded songs.[13][16] At one point, Springsteen was not going to include "I'm Goin' Down" on Born in the U.S.A., but later added it in place of "Pink Cadillac",[17][18] which he used as the B-side for "Dancing in the Dark".[18]
A rock song,[20] "I'm Goin' Down" is described by Uncut contributor John Lewis as having a country music influence, and "sound[ing] in places like Johnny Cash".[21] For other critics, the song contains rockabilly elements.[22][23] It begins with a short two-phrase guitar line,[6] followed by Weinberg's heavy drum beat,[19] one of the most prominent components in the song.[6][23] Music biographers Jean-Michel Guesdon and Philippe Margotin have commented on Bob Clearmountain's "signature" mixing of the track that makes the snare drum sound "[crack] like a whip".[6] These instruments are supplemented by bass by Tallent, a Hammond B-3 organ part by Federici, and piano by Bittan.[6] The song additionally includes a tenor saxophone solo by Clemons,[6][24] and hand-clapping by the band.[6][20] The music is based on a descending chord progression of A ("I'm goin")–E ("down, down down")–F♯m ("down, I'm goin")–D ("down"),[25] which is played throughout the track, while the bass guitar plays around the root of E.[26]
Lyrics and themes
Reviewers have commented on the contrast between the song's upbeat music and sad lyrics.[24][27][28] The song explores themes of sexual or romantic frustration,[29][30][31] loneliness,[29] and grief resulting from unsuccessful relationships.[20][32] Some reviewers have found humor in the lyrics,[19][30] which describe incidents such as the narrator's girlfriend rejecting his attempts at intimacy and sighing with boredom, as well as the couple returning home fighting after a date.[27] In concert, Springsteen has described "I'm Goin' Down" in jest as "one of my more insightful songs about men and women".[33] In live performances from 1984, he sometimes used variations of the following introduction for the song: "[First] you're making love to 'em all the time, three or four times a day. Then you come back a little bit later, and, uh-oh ... it's like 'Are you gonna make love to me tonight, or are we gonna wait for the full moon again', y'know?"[34][35]
In researcher Pamela Moss's feminist analysis of social class and gender in Springsteen's lyrics, she describes the singer's early-to-mid-1980s oeuvre as being filled with despair.[36] Moss states that within this context, men fault women for not helping them achieve their dream of finding "a promised land".[37] In "I'm Goin' Down", with the "deterioration of a desirable sexual relationship [the narrator] feels he is being 'set up' by the woman just so she will be able to reject him". According to Moss, the man sees the woman's rejection as interference holding back his attempt at a "liberation of the tedium of a working class existence".[37]
Release and reception
Born in the U.S.A. was released on June 4, 1984 by Columbia Records,[38] and "I'm Goin' Down", the album's sixth single,[39] on August 27, 1985.[40][41] The 7-inch single version includes B-side "Janey, Don't You Lose Heart",[42] while the 12-inch Maxi has "Janey, Don't You Lose Heart" and "Held Up Without a Gun".[43][n 2] In the United States, "I'm Goin' Down" entered the Billboard Hot 100 singles chart on September 7,[54] and peaked at No. 9 on October 25.[55] It was one of a record-tying seven top 10 singles to be released from a single album.[n 3] It also charted in Canada,[56] Australia,[57] Italy,[58] Sweden, and Germany.[43] No music video was made for the song.[59] The track was additionally released on 12" Single Collection in 1985,[60] and The Album Collection Vol. 1 1973–1984 in 2014.[61] Writer Greg Kot has noted that despite the single's chart success, the song was not included on Springsteen's 1995 Greatest Hits compilation.[62]
Critics have praised the saxophone solo by E Street Band member Clarence Clemons.[24][63]
"I'm Goin' Down" was generally well received by critics at the time of the album's release. Some reviewers considered the song to be among the best on Born in the U.S.A.,[23][64] including Ken Tucker of The Philadelphia Inquirer, who called the track one of the "emotional centerpieces on the album, and perhaps [one of] the finest examples of Springsteen's songwriting to date".[64]The Morning Call's Paul Willistein and The Cincinnati Enquirer's Cliff Radel similarly commended the songwriting.[31][65] Willistein wrote that the composition "evidences vulnerability, sensitivity and wisdom".[65] Among the musical components praised by critics were its percussion,[19][66] vocals,[31][66] and guitar,[66] as well as Clemons' saxophone solo.[63] The musicians' passion[23] and the song's fun energy[67] were other elements singled out by reviewers. Debbie Miller of Rolling Stone described the track as "wonderfully exuberant".[19]Sounds critic Sandy Robertson, reviewing a pre-release version of Born in the U.S.A. on which the title was listed as "Down Down Down", characterized the song as "a hit single if I ever heard one" and "the core that justifies most of the hype dumped on [Springsteen]".[66]
Some contemporary reviews were negative or neutral. The Vancouver Sun's Ian Gill dismissed the track as "simply a concession to the zit set".[68] About the song's choice as the album's sixth single, critic Jan DeKnock called the release "the dud of the week" that was "an uninspired ... filler cut".[69] David Hinkley of New York's Daily News considered it an unexceptional song on which Springsteen did not add much that was new to its common theme.[70]
Live performances
Springsteen has played "I'm Goin' Down" infrequently since the end of the Born in the U.S.A. Tour.[33] For his tours between 2002 and 2023, many of the set lists have been published on his official website, Brucespringsteen.net.[71][72] Of these, all of the singer's performances of the song are listed in the table below.[n 4]
Springsteen with a sign from an audience member requesting "I'm Goin' Down" on May 21, 2009 in East Rutherford
Springsteen sometimes takes song requests at concerts by collecting signs from the audience, as he did for "I'm Goin' Down" on May 21, 2009 in East Rutherford, New Jersey,[73][74] on February 27, 2016 in Rochester, New York,[75] and on August 2, 2008 in Foxborough, Massachusetts—where he introduced the song as "rarely played and even more rarely requested".[76][77]
A number of music critics have mentioned how live versions differ from the Born in the U.S.A. version.[78][79] Describing a performance of the song at an August 25, 1984 show in Landover, Maryland, critic Geoffrey Himes wrote that the "lean, synth-dominated album arrangement was supplanted by a full-tilt rock 'n' soul version".[79] Springsteen later admitted that the recorded version "had a swing ... we could never capture live".[80]
*Indicates that Springsteen performed the entire Born in the U.S.A. album at this concert.
Legacy and cover versions
"I'm Goin' Down" has received various ratings in overviews that consider all of Springsteen's songs. A 2017 article in NME calls it the fourth greatest Springsteen song of all time.[92] A 2014 Rolling Stone article ranks "I'm Goin' Down" as the 52nd best Bruce Springsteen song ever,[33] and it is included in writer June Skinner Sawyer's Tougher Than the Rest: 100 Best Bruce Springsteen Songs.[27] By contrast, in Counting Down Bruce Springsteen: His 100 Finest Songs, Jim Beviglia puts "I'm Goin' Down" as the 131st best Springsteen track,[93] calling it "a fun but relatively minor" work.[94] A critic for NJ.com described it as the worst song of Born in the U.S.A., and placed it in the No. 164 position of 318 of the singer's works.[95] In 2015, Uncut rated the song four stars out of five.[96]
In the Billboard 2014 article "Bruce Springsteen's Born in the U.S.A. at 30: Classic Track-By-Track Album Review", Caryn Rose called it the album's "most underrated song" and "the kind of good-time party song that Springsteen and E Street do best, sliding easily through the verses with a ... bouncing rhythm ... and a fun, jumping end".[24] The song is likewise described favorably in "Born in the U.S.A. has stood the test of time", a 2002 overview in New Jersey's Daily Record newspaper.[28]
The band Vampire Weekend released versions of "I'm Goin' Down" in 2010 and 2019.[108][109]
In September 2010, the online magazines Stereogum and Pitchfork noted how multiple bands had recently performed "I'm Goin' Down" in live settings within weeks of each other:[110][111]Vampire Weekend played the song in concert in Vancouver and a few days later in early September on a radio show in Seattle,[112] while Free Energy and Titus Andronicus performed it together later that month in Atlanta on their joint tour.[111] Like Frank Black, members of Vampire Weekend have expressed their high regard for Springsteen's composition, among whom vocalist Ezra Koenig had previously listened to the song "constantly",[113] and bassist Chris Baio cited Springsteen's "incredible melodies, incredible lyrics" that led the band to think "it would be exciting to put our spin on" the song.[114] Free Energy and Vampire Weekend each released a recording of it on iTunes in 2010.[108][115] Other releases include a Spotify single by Vampire Weekend in 2019.[109]
^Originally written for and rejected by Stevie Nicks, "Janey, Don't You Lose Heart" was recorded on June 16, 1983 at the Hit Factory, in New York City,[42] but features backing vocals by Nils Lofgren from a studio session in 1985.[44] It has been described as "a gentle, encouraging love song" that would not seem out of place on the country music charts,[45] and as a decidedly pop track with a pleasing chorus.[42] The song was later released on 12" Single Collection (1985), Tracks (1998), and 18 Tracks (1999).[46] Some reviewers have highlighted the value and collectible nature that non-album songs such as "Janey, Don't You Lose Heart", at the time only available on the single, represented for Springsteen fans.[47][48][49][50] "Held Up Without a Gun" had also appeared as the B-side of "Hungry Heart" (1980),[48] and was released on The Ties That Bind: The River Collection (2015).[51] Sources list multiple recording dates in February and April 1980 for the song,[52][53] which is 75 seconds in length,[52] and has a punk rock influence.[52][53] It tells the story of a "rocker who is cheated by his cigar-chomping manager",[48] which some critics have interpreted as a likely reference to Springsteen's own struggles with his former manager Mike Appel of Laurel Canyon Productions.[49][52]
^This is based on set lists that were captured in archived versions of his website in November 2008 (for the 2002—2008 tours), May 2017 (for the 2009–2017 tours), and February 2024 (for the 2023 tour).
^ ab"Classifiche". Musica e dischi (in Italian). Retrieved June 1, 2022. Set "Tipo" on "Singoli". Then, with "I'm going down" in the "Titolo" field, click "cerca".
"Dog Gone" (CD cover). Frank Black and the Catholics. Austria: Play It Again Sam Records. 1998.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
