Like the novel, Kassila wanted set the film in the 1930s, and for that, a possible authentic shooting environment was needed to get the impression of the period. In the end, a suitable destination can be found in the Nurmijärvi village, where the film was filmed.[1]
The film received a positive reception from critics when it was released. In 1955, the film won two Jussi Awards: for best direction (Matti Kassila) and best set design (Aarre Koivisto).[1][2][3]
Hilma's Name Day has often been called one of Kassila's best directorial works,[4] and even Agapetus, who wrote the original novel, is said to have been exceptionally pleased with the result.[1][5]
Leo Nordberg from Uusi Suomi called the film as Kassila's "most intact work up to that point", adding that he also appreciates the film's "homely Finnish tone".[1] Paula Talaskivi from Helsingin Sanomat wrote that "Kassila has done more work than usual for his portrayal of people." Also, the acting work of Tauno Palo and Edvin Laine was praised across the board.[1] Timo Malmi from Ilta-Sanomat estimates that "Edvin Laine in particular has the role of his life as the chief of the volunteer fire department in this warm Agapetus film adaptation."[6]
