He Ran All the Way is a 1951 American crime drama and film noir directed by John Berry and starring John Garfield and Shelley Winters.[2] Distributed by United Artists, it was produced independently by Roberts Pictures, a company named for Garfield's manager and business partner, Bob Roberts, and bankrolled by Garfield.[3] It would be Garfield's last film before his death in 1952 at the age of 39.
Plot
Petty thief Nick Robey botches a robbery, shooting and killing a policeman, and leaving his partner Al severely wounded. Nick escapes with over $10,000 and, deliberately losing himself in the crowd, makes his way to a local swimming pool. At the pool, he meets bakery worker Peg Dobbs, and accompanies her home to her family's apartment. Peg's mother, father and young brother leave to see a movie. When they return, Robey takes the family hostage until he can escape.
As a manhunt for Nick begins outside, he becomes increasingly paranoid. Peg's initial attraction to him is replaced by fear. Her mother and father plead with Nick to leave, to no avail. He permits Mr. Dobbs to leave for work, warning him of the consequences should the police be contacted. Peg continues to go to work. Her father tells her to stay away, but she returns later that night. Peg phones Nick's mother, asking her to meet Nick to give her some money, but she refuses. Peg agrees to go away with Nick and he gives her $1,500 to buy a new car.
The next day, Nick gets into a confrontation with Mr. Dobbs, but lets him leave when Peg returns. Poisoned by Dobbs' insistence that Peg will not buy the car, Nick refuses to believe Peg who insists that the car will be delivered to the front door after the dealer has the headlights repaired. As he leaves, Dobbs meets Mrs. Dobbs and tells her to take their son and not return and they go to the police. In the meantime, Nick notices how quiet the neighbourhood is and is scared that the police are outside. Nick violently takes Peg down the stairs toward the exit, terrifying her. Mr. Dobbs, who had been waiting outside, shoots at Nick when they reach the door. When Nick's gun drops beyond his reach and he orders Peg to hand it to him, she shoots him instead. A mortally wounded Nick crawls outside to the curb, in time to see his new car arrive. The police arrive shortly after Nick is dead.
The film was Garfield's last. He was "greylisted" following accusations of his involvement with the Communist Party USA. Testifying before the House Committee on Un-American Activities (aka HUAC), he repudiated communism, denied party membership, and claimed that he did not know any members of the Communist Party during his entire time in Hollywood, "because I was not a party member or associated in any shape, way, or form."[3][4] He testified on April 23, 1951, just two months before He Ran All the Way was scheduled to open, on June 19. Garfield died less than a year later, on May 21, 1952, at age 39.
Dalton Trumbo had signed to write the screen adaptation of Sam Ross's novel just weeks from starting the jail term resulting from his own testimony to HUAC, in 1947. According to Trumbo's son, Christopher, Guy Endore did some revisions to Trumbo's script, as did director Berry. In a 1997 letter to the Writers Guild of America West, which was determining the restoration of credits to blacklisted members, Trumbo's widow Cleo stated that their friend and fellow writer Hugo Butler had been asked by Trumbo to ensure that the script not be altered while he was incarcerated, and Butler restored much of the original material, adding some of his own.[3] The film opened in June 1951, the screenplay credited to Endore and Butler, and John Berry credited as the director.[5][6] Just prior to the premiere, Berry and Butler were subpoenaed by HUAC, and producer Bob Roberts removed their names from advertising, first in the trade press, and then in the general press as the film circulated.[7][8]
Trumbo was paid $5,000 and five percent of the producers' profits on condition that the picture would cost no more than $400,000, with the possibility that it might cost $100,000 less than that, but he complained to Roberts that the costs had grown to about $650,000, adding, "and that came right out of my pocket."[3]Variety reviewer "Bron." observed, "Production budget seems limited to insure safe returns," and predicted, "pic should do biz."[5] At the end of the year, the trade paper estimated that He Ran All the Way would gross $1 million in the domestic market (i.e., USA and Canada), its threshold for reporting the "top grossers" of the year.[9] Less than a month after Garfield's death in May 1952, United Artists announced it would rerelease the title, among three others, in summer of that year.[10]
John Garfield's stark performance of the fugitive who desperately contrives to save himself briefly from capture is full of startling glints from start to end. He makes a most odd and troubled creature, unused to the normal flow of life, unable to perceive the moral standards of decent people or the tentative advance of a good girl's love. And in Mr. Garfield's performance, vis-a-vis the rest of the cast, is conveyed a small measure of the irony and the pity that was in the book.[6]
Variety called the film "a taut gangster pic," adding, "Good production values keep a routine yarn fresh and appealing. Film is scripted, played and directed all the way with little waste motion, so that the suspense is steady and interest constantly sustained." Reviewer "Bron." commended both Garfield's and Winters's performances, as well as an "unusually good" supporting cast, and, among other personnel, singled out composer Franz Waxman ("Pull of pic is further hyped by a strong music score...") and director of photographyJames Wong Howe, for "some markedly effective camera shots...."[5]
More recently, film critic Dennis Schwartz has also written positively of Garfield's performance:
He Ran All the Way was the last film made by the brilliant John Garfield ... Garfield gives a terrific chilling performance as someone who is less like a cold-blooded killer than someone who has been rejected all his life by family and the outside world, and like a wounded animal goes on the run as a desperate man in search of someone to trust in this cold world.[11]
^ abcdCeplair, Larry; Trumbo, Christopher (2015). Dalton Trumbo: Blacklisted Hollywood Radical. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky. pp. 250–51. ISBN978-0-8131-4680-5.
^McGrath, Patrick J. (1993). John Garfield: The Illustrated Career in Films and on Stage. Jefferson, NC: McFarland. p. 156. ISBN978-0-7864-2848-9.
^ abcBron. (June 6, 1951). "He Ran All the Way". Variety. p. 6.
