National championship Conference title Conference division title or championship game berth
Notes
^ abcGeorge Pugh was forced out after the first six games of the 1991 season. Ray Bonner replaced Pugh as head coach and led Alabama A&M to a record of 2–3 over the final five games of the season. The Bulldogs finished 5–6 overall, tying for the Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference title with a mark of 5–2.