Following his prolific release history in 2022, having produced four studio projects that year, including his own The Alchemist Sandwich, Maman shared the news of the upcoming record on his social media on June 26, 2023.[1] Fellow artist Earl Sweatshirt promptly shared the announcement on his socials, revealing his prominent input.[2] Maman went on to tag more artists with guest appearances on the EP, including frequent collaborators Mike, Boldy James and Larry June,[3] the latter of which released a collaboration project with Maman only three months prior.[4] While it was speculated that the EP would be a joint album of the Alchemist of and Sweatshirt, neither artist confirmed it.[5]
According to the review aggregator Metacritic, Flying High received "generally favorable reviews" based on a weighted average score of 79 out of 100 from 6 critic scores.[11]
Clash's Robin Murray described it as a "stunning four-track feast, the only downside is that we don't hear more from such a formidable cast" and felt that "the brevity doesn't downplay the creativity".[7] Dylan Green of Pitchfork called it "breezy" and found that it contains "a space for rhymers in Alchemist's orbit to unspool for the fun of it". Green also wrote that "none of these songs sound like demos or leftovers, but Flying High doesn't reach for the stars, either."[10] Wesley McLean of Exclaim! described the album as "a delicious hors d'oeuvre served up while you're waiting for whatever three-course meal that Alchemist has coming next," while also dubbing it "a reminder that Alchemist's circle doubles as a roster of some of the best rappers around."[8]HipHopDX's Anthony Malone described the EP as "an enjoyable listen," but adds that "there’s a shrouding feeling that the legendary producer has gotten comfortable creatively."[9]