Fish screen

Fish screen at Redlands Canal, near Grand Junction, Colorado

A fish screen is designed to prevent fish from swimming or being drawn into an aqueduct, cooling water intake, intake tower, dam or other diversion on a river, lake or waterway where water is taken for human use. They are intended to supply debris-free water without harming aquatic life. Fish screens are typically installed to protect endangered species of fishes that would otherwise be harmed or killed when passing through industrial facilities such as steam electric power plants, hydroelectric generators, petroleum refineries, chemical plants, farm irrigation water and municipal drinking water treatment plants. However, many fish are killed or injured on screens or elsewhere in the intake structures.[1]

Design

Industrial facilities

Fish screens may be positive barriers (devices such as a perforated metal plate that physically prevents fish from passing) or behavioral barriers (devices that encourage fish to swim away). Most behavioral barriers are experimental and of unproven effectiveness.[2]: p. 4–19 

Diagram of typical vertical traveling screens used with industrial cooling water intake structures

Positive barriers are often effective at keeping aquatic organisms from entering a cooling system, but may also kill them by impinging them on the screens.[3] These barrier types are widely used and include:

  • Modified traveling screens
  • Fish handling and return systems
  • Horizontal, flat-plate screens with bypass water return systems
  • Cylindrical wedge wire screens
  • Fine-mesh screens
  • Fish net barriers.

Besides simply preventing fish from passing, fish screens are designed to minimize stress and injury that occur when fish impact the screen or are subjected to changes in water velocity and direction caused by the diversion.[2]: pp.4-3ff 

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has evaluated other barrier technologies and identified some as potentially effective, although not widely demonstrated (as of 2004):

  • Aquatic microfiltration barriers
  • Angled and modular inclined screens
  • Velocity caps.[2]: pp.4–15ff 

Some fish screens are designed to protect a single species of fish (for example, salmon) and are not necessarily effective at protecting other fish species. Some screens are capable of protecting more than one species or type of life. Additionally, some screens may effectively protect juvenile and adult fish, but not fish eggs and larvae.[4]

The cost of a fish screen varies from thousands of US dollars for small, low-flow-rate screens to millions of US dollars in the case of very large custom-designed systems that filter a large flow of water. Maintenance costs can be significant, including repairs, removing trash, and adjusting the equipment for changes in stream conditions.

Non-industrial applications

For some low volume, non-industrial water diversion applications, there are screens available that have no moving parts, do not require electricity, and have very little need for maintenance.[5]

Impacts on aquatic life

The Indian Point Energy Center in New York. Over a billion fish eggs and larvae were claimed to be killed in its cooling system each year while it was still operating.

Many power plants and other industries in the U.S. continue to use screens that impinge fish. For example, the cooling system at the Indian Point Energy Center in New York was claimed to kill over a billion fish eggs and larvae annually.[6] At the Bay Shore Power Plant in Ohio, 46 million fish were killed over an 18-month period.[3][7] Organisms that pass through the screens are killed or stressed (depending on the species) as they become entrained in the cooling system.[4] 208 million fish eggs and over 2 billion small and larval fish were entrained at the Bay Shore plant over the same 18 months.[7] EPA estimates that billions of fish and other organisms are killed each year in cooling water intakes.[8]

In the United States, the National Marine Fisheries Service, a division of NOAA, mandates positive-barrier fishscreens in most new diversions from waterways where endangered or threatened fish species occur. Some existing unscreened diversions whose construction pre-dates fish-screen mandates are allowed to continue operating by grandfather rule.[citation needed]

The U.S. Clean Water Act requires EPA to issue regulations on industrial cooling water intake structures.[9] The agency issued regulations for new facilities in 2001 (amended 2003),[10] and for existing facilities in 2014.[11]

See also

References

  1. ^ "Environmental and social aspects of cooling". Cooling Power Plants. London: World Nuclear Association. Retrieved 2019-09-21.
  2. ^ a b c "Chapter 4. Efficacy of Cooling Water Intake Structure Technologies". Technical Development Document for the Final Section 316(b) Phase II Existing Facilities Rule (Report). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 2004. EPA 821-R-04-007.
  3. ^ a b Schmitz, Christy (2009-08-19). "One Fish, Two Fish, 46 Million Lake Erie Dead Fish". Toledo City Paper. Toledo, OH: Adams Street Publishing Co.
  4. ^ a b EPA (2002). "National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System—Proposed Regulations to Establish Requirements for Cooling Water Intake Structures at Phase II Existing Facilities; Proposed Rule." 67 FR 17136. 2002-04-09.
  5. ^ "Fish Screens for Irrigation & Hydropower". Hood River, OR: Farmers Conservation Alliance. Retrieved 2019-09-21.
  6. ^ McGeehan, Patrick (2015-05-12). "Fire Prompts Renewed Calls to Close the Indian Point Nuclear Plant". New York Times.
  7. ^ a b Henry, Tom (2010-03-30). "FirstEnergy to install devices to divert fish". Toledo Blade.
  8. ^ Fact Sheet: Final Regulations to Establish Requirements for Cooling Water Intake Structures at Existing Facilities (Report). EPA. May 2014. EPA 821-F-14-001.
  9. ^ Clean Water Act, Section 316(b), 33 U.S.C. § 1316.
  10. ^ EPA. "National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System: Regulations Addressing Cooling Water Intake Structures for New Facilities." Final rule: 2001-12-18, Federal Register, 66 FR 65255. Amended: 2003-06-19, 68 FR 36749.
  11. ^ EPA. "National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System—Final Regulations To Establish Requirements for Cooling Water Intake Structures at Existing Facilities and Amend Requirements at Phase I Facilities" Final rule. Federal Register, 79 FR 48300. 2014-08-15.