Engstler was considered a five-star recruit and the ninth-best player in the 2018 class by ESPN.[12] On October 19, 2017, she committed to play college basketball for Syracuse over offers from Ohio State and Miami (Florida). Engstler was drawn to the school because of its proximity to her home and its reputed program in broadcast journalism,[13] her intended major.[8]
College career
Engstler came off the bench during her freshman season at Syracuse.[14] On February 21, 2019, she recorded a season-high 17 points, six rebounds, three assists and three blocks in a 90–63 win over Pittsburgh.[15] As a freshman, Engstler averaged 4.9 points and 4.5 rebounds in 14.2 minutes per game.[16] With the departure of small forward Miranda Drummond, she entered the starting lineup in her sophomore season.[17] On December 20, 2019, Engstler posted 13 points, a season-high 17 rebounds and five assists in a 77–63 victory over Michigan State.[18] On January 5, 2020, she recorded a season-high 22 points and 15 rebounds in a 74–63 victory against Notre Dame.[19] As a sophomore, Engstler averaged nine points, 9.2 rebounds and 1.6 blocks per game, leading her team in rebounds and blocks.[20] She suffered from depression during the season. Engstler improved her endurance and mental health by exercising routinely during COVID-19 pandemic lockdown under the guidance of her older sister, Danielle. She lost about 40 lbs (18 kg) in the offseason through exercise and dieting.[21][22]
Engstler returned to a reserve role in her junior season, but remained one of Syracuse's most productive players.[22] In the quarterfinals of the 2021 ACC tournament, she made a game-winning, buzzer beating layup in a 90–89 win over Florida State.[23] Engstler registered a career-high 21 points and 10 rebounds in a 72–59 loss to Louisville at the semifinals.[24] She was selected to the all-tournament second team.[25] As a junior, Engstler averaged 10.5 points and 9.1 rebounds per game, earning ACC Co-Sixth Player of the Year honors.[26] She led Syracuse in rebounds, steals and three-point field goal percentage.[27]
For her senior season, Engstler transferred to Louisville, being drawn to the program by head coach Jeff Walz.[28] On January 2, 2022, she made a game-winning layup with three seconds left in a 50–48 victory over Georgia Tech.[29] On March 26, Engstler matched her season-high of 20 points while grabbing 10 rebounds in a 76–64 win against Tennessee at the Sweet 16 of the NCAA tournament.[30] She helped Louisville reach the Final Four of the tournament.[31] As a senior, Engstler averaged 11.9 points, 9.4 rebounds, 2.7 steals and 1.8 blocks per game, and was named to the first-team All-Atlantic Coast Conference and All-Defensive Team.[32] On March 29, she declared for the 2022 WNBA draft, forgoing her additional year of college eligibility granted due to the COVID-19 pandemic.[33]
Professional career
WNBA
Engstler was selected by the Indiana Fever with the fourth overall pick in the 2022 WNBA draft.[32] On August 12, 2022, she scored a season-high 18 points, five rebounds and three blocks in an 82–70 loss to the Washington Mystics.[34] In her rookie season, Engstler averaged 5.2 points and 5.2 rebounds per game, making six starts in 35 games.[35]
Prior to the start of the 2023 WNBA Training Camp, the Fever waived Engstler.[36] After being waived by the Fever, Engstler signed a training camp contract with the Washington Mystics.[37] Engstler did not make the final roster for the Mystics after appearing in the preseason.[38] On June 14, 2023, Engstler signed a Hardship Contract with the Minnesota Lynx.[39] Engstler spent just over a month with the Lynx before Jessica Shepard returned from her illness and Engstler was released from her hardship contract.[40]