In the fall of 1861, after the outbreak of the American Civil War, Colman assisted in raising a company of volunteers to answer President Abraham Lincoln's call for three-year enlistments. Colman was made 1st Lieutenant of his company, which became Company A of the 18th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry Regiment. The regiment mustered into service on March 15, 1862, under Colonel James S. Alban, who selected Lieutenant Colman as Adjutant.[3]: 656
The 18th Wisconsin arrived at St. Louis on March 31, and then took barges up the Tennessee River to Pittsburg Landing, Tennessee. The regiment arrived around noon on Saturday, April 5, and were assigned to the command of General Benjamin Prentiss, marching the rest of the day to reach his headquarters, going into camp at dusk without supper. During the night, Confederate forces under Albert Sidney Johnston marched to within two miles of the Union lines and attacked near dawn on Sunday, April 6, the start of the Battle of Shiloh. The regiment was hastily arranged into battle lines. Initially, their left was supported by the 15th Michigan Volunteer Infantry Regiment, but they had not yet been supplied with ammunition and were forced to withdraw as a result.[3]: 657 After about two hours of fighting, the entire division began a retreat, it was around this time that Lieutenant Colman was severely wounded when he was shot in the head. He was carried from the field by 2nd Lieutenant Thomas J. Potter, who was also wounded in the battle.[3]: 658 Lieutenant Colman's life was likely saved by Potter's action, as he was considered unlikely to survive the head wound. Both Colman and Potter were sent home on medical leave following their injuries. Potter died of his wound five months later. Colman carried the bullet in his head for the rest of his life.[2]
In January 1865, he was commissioned Lieutenant Colonel for the newly organized 49th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry Regiment and joined the regiment in Missouri where they engaged in guard duty until the end of the war. The regiment mustered out of service on November 8, 1865. Colman received a promotion to Colonel shortly before mustering out.[4]
Postbellum career
Shortly after the war, Colman was appointed Superintendent of Public Property in Madison and served there for about one and a half years. After that he became involved in the banking industry and was, for nine years, treasurer of the Fond Du Lac Savings Bank.[4] In 1877, Colman returned to Empire, Wisconsin, and was elected Sheriff of Fond du Lac County for a two-year term, running on the Republican Party ticket. He remained in Empire, working as cashier for the Mihills Manufacturing Company and was elected City Treasurer for two terms.[2] In 1881, he was elected to represent Fond du Lac County in the Wisconsin State Senate for the 1882 and 1883 sessions, but with the ratification of changes to senate and assembly terms in 1881, Colman's term was effectively extended through 1884, though no additional legislative business occurred that year.[5]
On September 4, 1898, he died in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, while attending services at Grace Episcopal Church.[1]